SPIE Membership Get updates from SPIE Newsroom
  • Newsroom Home
  • Astronomy
  • Biomedical Optics & Medical Imaging
  • Defense & Security
  • Electronic Imaging & Signal Processing
  • Illumination & Displays
  • Lasers & Sources
  • Micro/Nano Lithography
  • Nanotechnology
  • Optical Design & Engineering
  • Optoelectronics & Communications
  • Remote Sensing
  • Sensing & Measurement
  • Solar & Alternative Energy
  • Sign up for Newsroom E-Alerts
  • Information for:
SPIE Photonics West 2019 | Register Today

SPIE Defense + Commercial Sensing 2019 | Call for Papers

2019 SPIE Optics + Photonics | Call for Papers



Print PageEmail PageView PDF


Precision electroforming mirrors open new vistas, both tiny and cosmic

High-precision electroforming replica technology offers lightweight, lower-cost manufacture of optical systems from x-rays to the far-IR.
15 May 2012, SPIE Newsroom. DOI: 10.1117/2.1201205.003936

The European Space Agency (ESA) decided in the early 1990s to create the XMM-Newton telescope. According to ESA mission objectives, it would be an “x-ray telescope four times more powerful than any other telescope in the world and with the capability of observing ten times more x-ray sources in the universe." Optical specialists were handed a challenge: how to produce 200 square meters of highly reflective thin optical mirrors just 0.4–1mm thick possessing an ultrasmooth surface with roughness less than 0.4nm.

Figure 1. One mirror module in the European Space Agency's XMM-Newton telescope. (Image courtesy of Media Lario Technologies, MLT.)

We developed high-precision electroforming (e-forming) replication technology to make mirrors of the necessary quality, size, and performance requested by the scientific community (see Figure 1).1 In the e-forming process, metal ions from an anode are deposited through electrolyte solution onto an electroconductive surface called a master. A metal skin is built up to desired thickness and then removed from the master, forming a self-supporting structure. With the support of ESA and the Italian Space Agency, we progressively improved and optimized the technique. Stringent control over the internal stress and thickness of the metal ion deposit allows an easy release of the mirror from the master, enhancing the optical performance and increasing the lifetime of the master copy.

The core advantage of our approach is the ability to precisely reproduce the master surface many times over without performing any further polishing steps on the final mirror. The result is significant cost and cycle time savings of over 50% when compared with traditional technologies. The savings remain true even for complex surface profiles such as toroidal and off-axis shapes. We are currently applying precision e-forming replication to challenges in advanced EUV lithography and single-aperture multispectral visible long-wave IR (VIS-LWIR) sensors for space and defense applications.

Figure 2. Grazing incidence collector for advanced extreme-UV lithography equipment during integration at the optical bench. (Image courtesy MLT.)
Table 1.Shape accuracy of MLT e-formed mirror vs. aperture.
Aperture (mm)Shape accuracy
(PTV λ/#)
150 4
125 6
100 11
75 21

Figure 3. Interferometric measurement of mirror accuracy. λ/4 PTV (peak to valley) and λ/16 RMS were obtained through the replica process. λ: Wavelength.

Microchips are produced by photolithography using short-wavelength UV light. As more and more circuits are packed onto ever smaller chips, the semiconductor industry has shifted to new lithographic-manufacturing technologies that use shorter wavelengths in the EUV spectrum. The shorter the wavelength, the finer the circuits it can draw on a chip. Conventional lenses cannot focus, or collect, EUV rays. Consequently, developers of advanced EUV lithography equipment need an efficient mechanism with reflective optics for collecting and transporting EUV light. Their requirements are stringent both in terms of operative environmental conditions and performance of the optical system.

The solution to this problem turned out to be the ‘reverse’ configuration of the space telescope (see Figure 2).2 Accordingly, we designed and produced a new EUV collector. This design provides integrated thermal management capable of dissipating a thermal load of 15kW, maintains the optical performance of the collector under full source power operation, has a collection efficiency up to 32%, and is capable of 500W EUV power at the intermediate focus. The optics have a reflective layer with a one-year lifetime and flexible configurations tailored to the specific source and scanner requirements, e.g., the number of mirror shells, reflective layer, and alignment and mounting interfaces.

Figure 4. Single-aperture multispectral sensor prototype for defense surveillance. (Image courtesy MLT.)

Precision e-forming replication technology also has promise for multi- and hyperspectral sensors for defense surveillance and space-based Earth observation. A key challenge presented by the developers of such sensors is how to produce compact, lightweight imaging systems at a reasonable price, working in a wide range of wavelengths (typically VIS-LWIR corresponding to the range 450nm–12μm). These multispectral sensors consist of several optical systems based on lenses using expensive materials and with significant mass and overall dimensions. Alternative solutions based on a reflective approach, which requires totally aspherical off-axis optical design, have been studied. But they were too expensive, heavy, and complex to be produced at the time.

Now, our precision e-forming technique has made the use of multispectral off-axis mirrors possible. We can produce such lightweight and low-roughness optics with complex design at reasonable cost and cycle time (see Figure 3 and Table 1). We are currently working on the design and production of a multispectral off-axis demonstration project for defense surveillance and space-based Earth observation applications (see Figure 4 and Table 2). We believe the technology can be pushed even further. We have several ongoing studies in cooperation with various scientific institutes to improve the thermo-mechanical performance of the e-formed mirrors, and hope to expand their application in the future.

Table 2.Key requirements of multispectral sensor for defense surveillance. VIS: Visible.
Wavebands ofNear-IR (NIR, 0.45–1.2μm)
Wavebands of Near-IR (NIR, 0.45–1.2μm)
operation Mid-IR (MIR, 3–5μm)
Far-IR (FIR, 8–12μm)
Modulation Nominal: >70% over entire field of
transfer view at 25 cycles/mm
function Operational: >50%
Effective 94mm
F/no: 1.45
Field of view 4:3×3:1° (D=5:3°)
Sensor VIS and NIR: 1024×768 pixels, pixel pitch: 9.4μm
Sensor MIR and FIR 640 ×510 pixels, pixel pitch: 17μm
Qualification MIL-STD810

Giuseppe Borghi, Mara Bello
Media Lario Technologies (MLT)
Bosisio Parini, Italy

Giuseppe Borghi is MLTs' vice president of marketing and sales, and also head of the Space-Terrestrial Imaging Optics business unit. He joined MLT in 2008 and leads the MLT Imaging Optics Technology Road Map. He has published more than 30 papers in international journals and conferences on x-ray optics, space systems, and robotics.

Mara Bello joined MLT in 1996 as a member of the team in charge of the manufacturing and integration of the XMM mirror modules. Since 1998 she has been responsible for tactical marketing.

1. Y. Stockman, P. Barzin, H. Hansen, E. Mazy, J. P. Tock, D. de Chambure, R. Laine, D. Kampf, R. Banham, M. Canali, G. Grisoni, P. G. Radaelli, XMM flight model mirror module testing, Proc. SPIE 3766, p. 51-61, 1999. doi:10.1117/12.363663
2. G. Bianucci, A. Bragheri, G. L. Cassol, R. Ghislanzoni, R. Mazzoleni, F. E. Zocchi, Enabling the 22nm node via grazing incidence collectors integrated into the DPP source for EUVL HVM, Proc. SPIE 7969, p. 79690B, 2011. doi:10.1117/12.879396