SPIE Membership Get updates from SPIE Newsroom
  • Newsroom Home
  • Astronomy
  • Biomedical Optics & Medical Imaging
  • Defense & Security
  • Electronic Imaging & Signal Processing
  • Illumination & Displays
  • Lasers & Sources
  • Micro/Nano Lithography
  • Nanotechnology
  • Optical Design & Engineering
  • Optoelectronics & Communications
  • Remote Sensing
  • Sensing & Measurement
  • Solar & Alternative Energy
  • Sign up for Newsroom E-Alerts
  • Information for:
SPIE Photonics West 2018 | Call for Papers

SPIE Defense + Commercial Sensing 2018 | Call for Papers




Print PageEmail PageView PDF


Simple filters enable x-ray polarization measurements

A novel transmissive technology could add a polarimetry capability to future high-energy astronomical observatories with large effective areas.
13 April 2009, SPIE Newsroom. DOI: 10.1117/2.1200904.1585

Measurements of the degree and angle of polarization of emission from astronomical sources enable physical characterization of the objects and environmental conditions from which the photons originate. However, a lack of suitable instrumentation in the x-ray and gamma-ray regimes has been frustrating astronomers for over three decades. To date, only one unambiguous astrophysical x-ray polarization measurement has been obtained: the Crab Nebula was observed to exhibit 19% linear polarization at 2.6keV.1

Conventional x-ray polarimetry relies on Bragg reflection or Thomson scattering, but instruments operating on the basis of either effect tend to suffer from low sensitivity. The next generation of large x-ray observatories currently under study—such as the International X-ray Observatory2 (IXO) and Astro-H3—have triggered renewed interest in practical x-ray polarization measurements. Device efficiency improvements have been facilitated by the development of novel gaseous detectors that can operate in the x-ray regime.4,5 We have been pursuing an alternative approach to achieve x-ray polarimetry by developing dichroic filters that work in an analogous way to standard optical Polaroid® film.6–8 These low-mass devices could add a polarimetry capability to the existing focal-plane microcalorimeter instruments proposed for these new observatories, while avoiding the cost and complexity of developing and operating additional detectors solely dedicated to x-ray polarimetry.6

At visible wavelengths, polarization can be detected using highly ordered materials such as H-sheet Polaroid, a polyvinyl alcohol polymer impregnated with iodine. Polarization of 33.17keV x-rays using ordinary H-sheet material was successfully analyzed for the first time in 1997.9 However, the theory behind the operation of such ‘wire-grid’ dichroic polarizers predicted that these materials should be ineffective at x-ray wavelengths. Instead, the observed x-ray dichroism is a consequence of structure in a material's x-ray absorption coefficient within a few tens of electron volts of an absorption edge, the so-called ‘x-ray absorption fine structure’ (XAFS). In most materials without any substantial anisotropy in the orientations of the bonds, the XAFS does not depend significantly on the polarization angle of the incident x-ray emission. However, in the highly ordered materials that form the basis of our dichroic-filter concept, the presence or absence of a vacant allowed state along either of the material's axes leads to an XAFS polarization dependence.

Figure 1. Energy spectra for an inclusion compound of 1-bromoadamantane in a thiourea host. The red and black curves are for χ=90and 0°, respectively, where χ is the angle between the crystal's dichroic axis and the polarization direction of the photons. Such measurements were first reported by Chao and collaborators.10

Figure 1 shows dichroism in the bromine K-edge XAFS for an inclusion compound of 1-bromoadamantane in a thiourea host, which was first reported by Chao and his team in 2003.10 Polarization information can be obtained by observing the difference in filter transmission as a function of azimuthal rotation with respect to the incident (polarized) x-rays. Figure 2 shows the change in transmittance versus rotation about the synchrotron beam. Measurements of a statistically significant modulation of this kind for an astrophysical object would provide direct evidence of polarized x-ray emission.

Figure 2. Variation in transmission of a 1-bromoadamantane/thiourea inclusion compound as a function of the azimuthal rotation of the sample about the beam direction (χ) at an energy of 13.476keV (with an uncertainty of 0.5eV) in synchrotron testing at the Daresbury Synchrotron Radiation Source (UK).

The case for x-ray polarimetry measurements at discrete energies was originally made in the context of observations of accretion disks around black holes.11 In addition, polarimetric observations of the x-ray spectrum of the accretion disk in an active galactic nucleus have shown that the degree and angle of polarization of its continuum emission are strong functions of energy, black-hole mass, accretion rate, and the disk's inclination angle.12 Measuring polarization at discrete energies also allows direct assessment of the ‘dragging of inertial frames’ (the Lense-Thirring effect), where rotation of the plane of polarization increases with greater photon energies. The origin of this rotation is relativistic. The energy dependence is observed because higher-energy photons tend to come from smaller radii in the accretion disk, and thus are associated with locations that experience a stronger gravitational field.13,14 The physical properties of the system—such as the specific angular momentum of the black hole and the disk's inclination—play an important role. The effect can be observed by direct measurement of x-ray polarization at discrete energies in combination with detailed models.15

In summary, our research enables production of novel materials that act as transmissive x-ray polarizing filters. These simple, low-mass devices could add an x-ray polarimetry capability to the high energy-resolution detectors of the planned new generation of large x-ray observatories. Over 30 years after the first measurement of x-ray polarization in the Crab Nebula, these filters (or alternative devices under development elsewhere) may finally open up the field of x-ray polarimetry to studies of the most extreme objects in the sky.

The focus of our current research is to develop and test a number of materials that are predicted to have significant dichroism, and demonstrate their effectiveness as polarizing filters at energies of 1–10keV. A specific aim is to generate target materials below 5keV, where the flux from typical astronomical targets and the effective area of future x-ray telescopes (such as IXO) are highest.

Adrian Martindale, Nigel Bannister, Daniel Cotton, George Fraser
Space Research Centre
University of Leicester
Leicester, UK
Kenneth Harris, Benson Kariuki, Ben Palmer
Department of Chemistry
Cardiff University
Cardiff, UK
Steve Collins
Diamond Light Source Ltd.
Didcot, UK
Greg Solan, Andrew Armitage
Department of Chemistry
University of Leicester
Leicester, UK
Mervyn Roy
Department of Physics and Astronomy
University of Leicester
Leicester, UK