Proceedings Volume 5030

Medical Imaging 2003: Physics of Medical Imaging

cover
Proceedings Volume 5030

Medical Imaging 2003: Physics of Medical Imaging

View the digital version of this volume at SPIE Digital Libarary.

Volume Details

Date Published: 5 June 2003
Contents: 12 Sessions, 108 Papers, 0 Presentations
Conference: Medical Imaging 2003 2003
Volume Number: 5030

Table of Contents

icon_mobile_dropdown

Table of Contents

All links to SPIE Proceedings will open in the SPIE Digital Library. external link icon
View Session icon_mobile_dropdown
  • Imaging Physics I
  • X-Ray Detectors I
  • CT
  • Breast Imaging I
  • X-Ray Detectors II
  • Novel Imaging Methods
  • Breast Imaging II
  • Volume Imaging - US/Tomosynthesis
  • Imaging Physics II
  • X-Ray Detectors III
  • Breast Imaging III
  • Poster Session
Imaging Physics I
icon_mobile_dropdown
Fundamental limitations imposed by x-ray interactions on the modulation transfer function of existing x-ray detectors
George Hajdok, Jerry J. Battista, Ian A. Cunningham
The development of new detectors for diagnostic x-ray imaging is a complex and expensive endeavour. An understanding of fundamental performance potential and limitations is therefore critical to the wise allocation of research resources. We present a Monte Carlo study in which the fundamental spatial resolution limitations imposed by x-ray interactions were determined for both direct conversion amorphous selenium (a-Se) and indirect conversion cesium iodide (CsI) detectors. Using a simulated infinitesimal x-ray beam, the absorbed energy point spread function (PSF) in each detector material was scored within rectilinear bin sizes of 5 mm for incident x-ray energies between 10 and 100 keV. The modulation transfer function (MTF) was determined from each simulated PSF and characterized in terms of the 50% MTF frequency, f50, and the equivalent passband, Ne. Both materials demonstrated: (i) a drop in f50 (a-Se: 25%, CsI: 85%) and Ne (a-Se: 45%, CsI: 75%) immediately above the K-edge energy due to re-absorption of characteristic radiation, and (ii) a moderate recovery of f50 and Ne levels with further increase in energy. In addition, within the diagnostic energy range and spatial frequency range of 0 -- 20 cycles/mm, the values of the fundamental MTF due to x-ray interactions remain above 50%. In general, we conclude that existing amorphous selenium and cesium iodide detectors operate far from fundamental spatial resolution limits in both mammography and radiography applications. Further reduction in detector element size will potentially improve spatial resolution in these detectors.
Impact of resolution and noise characteristics of digital radiographic detectors on the detectability of lung nodules
The current system performance metrics for Digital Radiographic detectors describe physical parameters, such as resolution (Modulation Transfer Function), noise (Noise Power Spectrum) and efficiency (Detective Quantum Efficiency). However, little has been done to substantiate the impact of these quantitative image quality metrics on a detector's utility for specific clinical tasks. In order to simulate the effects of these physical parameters, image modification routines were developed capable of modifying a perfect input image to the resolution and noise characteristics specified by an input MTF and input NPS and included sampling effects such as aliasing. Experimental verification of these routines showed excellent correspondence between the resolution and noise properties of the output images and the input NPS and MTF curves. In order to investigate the effect of noise and resolution on signal detection tasks, high-quality images containing simulated lesions are altered by the image modification routines to the resolution and noise properties of two commercial digital radiographic detectors, one direct and one indirect. The sets of modified images had noise properties consistent with acquisitions at comparable, clinically relevant exposures for the two detectors. An observer study is performed with the resultant images followed by a Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis. The results revealed the direct detector had a higher area under the ROC curve with a statistically significant difference for a 2.75 mm nodule (Az = 0.90 vs. 0.76, p<0.01). The findings illustrated the connection between the physical performance metrics and utility for the signal detection tasks necessary for clinical use.
X-Ray Detectors I
icon_mobile_dropdown
Charge transport and trapping-limited sensitivity and resolution of pixellated x-ray image detectors
Charge transport and trapping-limited sensitivity and signal spreading over neighboring pixels of a direct conversion pixellated x-ray image detector are calculated by using the final trapped charge distributions across the photoconductor and the weighting potential of the individual pixel. The analytical expressions for the final trapped charge distributions across the photoconductor are derived by analytically solving the continuity equation for both types of carriers (electrons and holes). We calculate collected charges at different pixels by considering square pixels arranged in a two dimensional array. We calculate the amount of collected charge per unit incident radiation, the x-ray sensitivity, in terms of normalized parameters; (a) the normalized absorption depth (= absorption depth/photoconductor thickness), (b) normalized electron schubweg (schubweg/thickness), (c) normalized hole schubweg, and (d) normalized pixel pitch (pixel size/thickness). The composite (finely sampled) line spread function (LSF) is calculated by calculating collected charges at different pixels and by considering diagnostic x-ray irradiation along a line. The modulation transfer function (MTF) due to distributed carrier trapping is calculated by taking Fourier transform of composite LSF and correcting for the square sampling aperture. The charge transport and trapping-limited sensitivity and resolution of pixellated x-ray detectors mostly depend on the mobility and lifetime product of charges that move towards the pixel electrodes and the extent of dependence increases with decreasing normalized pixel pitch. The polarity (negative or positive signal) and the quantity of induced signals in the surrounding pixels depend on the bias polarity and the rate of trapping of both types of carriers. Optimal sensitivity and resolution can be attained by ensuring that the carriers which drift towards the pixel electrodes have a schubweg much longer than the sample thickness.
Active pixel image sensor for large-area medical imaging
Karim S. Karim, Yurii K. Vygranenko, Alfredo Avila-Munoz, et al.
The most widely used pixel architecture is a passive pixel sensor (PPS) where the pixel consists of a detector and an a-Si:H thin-film transistor readout switch. While the PPS has the advantage of being compact and amenable towards high-resolution imaging, the data line capacitance, resistance, and the column charge amplifiers add a large noise component to the PPS that reduces the minimum readable sensor input signal. Building upon previous research into active pixel sensor (APS) based amplified pixel readout circuits, this work investiates a current-mediated APS (C-APS) x-ray detection array for diagnostic medical imaging applications. Preliminary tests indicate linear performance, and a programmable circuits gain via choice of supply voltage and sampling time. In addition, the performance of C-APS amplified pixels is measured from both, a-Si TFT metastability and noise performance perspectives. Theory and measurements indicate that the C-APS pixel architecture is promising for diagnostic medical imaging modalities including low noise, real-time fluoroscopy.
Optimization of flat-panel detector characteristics and processing using quantitative image quality techniques
David L. Wilson, Yuhao Jiang, Yogesh Srinivas, et al.
Although physical measurements such as detective quantum efficiency (DQE) and modulation transfer function (MTF) provide insights, quantitative optimization of x-ray flat panel detectors requires consideration of image quality as perceived by humans. Using experiments and human observer models, we quantified image quality as the ability to detect targets such as stents and guidewires used in interventional angiography. We realistically simulated direct and indirect flat panel detectors over a range of exposures to create realistic fluoroscopy sequences. We performed objective, m-alternative adaptive forced choice experiments and applied models of human detection to fit almost all experiments and predict results for similar tasks and processing. With regard to pixel size, the best size at low fluoroscopic exposures for detecting a 400 μm guide wire with a realistic, indirect detector was at about 200 μm and depended upon such device parameters as electronic noise. For both indirect and direct detectors at higher exposures, noise was not limiting, and a small pixel was desirable. With regard to binning, we determined that binning is desirable at low exposures even for detection of small objects such as a guide wire. A new alternate binning method was found to have superior image quality by utilizing the ability of humans to temporally fuse alternating images binned at different orientations. Comparing to magnification of analog image intensifiers, we determined that flat panel images can be digitally magnified without loss of image quality at a decreased average exposure.
N-i-p-SiNx and p-i-n-SiNx x-ray image detectors for medical applications
Sen-Shyong Fann, Yeu-Long Jiang, Huey-Liang Hwang
An innovative hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) p-i-n photodiode based x-ray detector for medical imaging applications has been developed in this work. Basically, the detector is a p-i-n photodiode, with a very simple modification by depositing a stacked silicon nitride (SiNx) layer on the p-layer (n-i-p-SiNx) or n-layer (p-i-n-SiNx) of this diode. The dielectric layer functioned as the major charge storage element of the pixel, and p-i-n as the photon-charge converter, separately. The charge storage capacity is larger as the nitride layer is thinner. Consequently, dynamic range, linearity, and data retention of the image array were significantly improved. The novel detector also offers a scheme to independently optimize the photo sensitivity and charge storage capacity of a p-i-n photodiode based pixel. Instead of the conventional p-i-n photodiodes, the novel detectors are proposed to employ in the active matrix, flat-panel imager, with the favor that the signal readout electronics and the TFT driving circuitry are unchanged. The changes include only the bias voltage, whch as a bi-level waveform, as well as the timing for turning on/off the switching thin film transistors (TFTs). The fundamentals of the n-i-p-SiNx and p-i-n-SiNx detectors are addressed, and the performances of these two novel detectors and the conventional p-i-n photodiode are compared. Additionally, the different performances, such as the speed, between n-i-p-SiNx and p-i-n-SiNx will be particularly discussed.
Clinical performance of a 14-in. x 14-in. real-time amorphous selenium flat-panel detector
Olivier Tousignant, Yves Demers, Luc Laperriere, et al.
Clinical evaluation results are presented using a large area, real time, amorphous selenium (a:Se), flat panel detector (FPD). The detector comprises of 1 mm thick amorphous selenium layer deposited onto a TFT panel that has a pixel pitch of .15 mm. The field of view of the detector is about 14” x 14” that is large enough to be used in R/F as well as general angiography application including digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Due to its high spatial resolution and low noise performance, it is shown that the detector is well suited to replace conventional image intensifier systems as well as film-screen systems.
Mercuric iodide and lead iodide x-ray detectors for radiographic and fluoroscopic medical imaging
George Zentai, Larry D. Partain, Raisa Pavlyuchkova, et al.
Mercuric iodide (HgI2) and lead iodide (PbI2) have been under development for several years as direct converter layers in digital x-ray imaging. Previous reports have covered the basic electrical and physical characteristics of these and several other materials. We earlier reported on 5cm x 5cm and 10cm x 10cm size imagers, direct digital radiography X-ray detectors, based on photoconductive polycrystalline mercuric iodide deposited on a flat panel thin film transistor (TFT) array, as having great potential for use in medical imaging, NDT, and security applications. This paper, presents results and comparison of both lead iodide and mercuric iodide imagers scaled up to 20cm x 25cm sizes. Both the mercuric iodide and lead iodide direct conversion layers are vacuum deposited onto TFT array by Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD). This process has been successfully scaled up to 20cm x 25cm -- the size required in common medical imaging applications. A TFT array with a pixel pitch of 127 microns was used for this imager. In addition to increasing detector size, more sophisticated, non-TFT based small area detectors were developed in order to improve analysis methods of the mercuric and lead iodide photoconductors. These small area detectors were evaluated in radiographic mode, continuous fluoroscopic mode and pulsed fluoroscopic mode. Mercuric iodide coating thickness ranging between 140 microns and 300 microns and lead iodide coating thickness ranging between 100 microns and 180 microns were tested using beams with energies between 40 kVp and 100 kVp, utilizing exposure ranges typical for both fluoroscopic and radiographic imaging. Diagnostic quality radiographic and fluoroscopic images have been generated at up to 15 frames per second. Mercuric iodide image lag appears adequate for fluoroscopic imaging. The longer image lag characteristics of lead iodide make it only suitable for radiographic imaging. For both material the MTF is determined primarily by the aperture and pitch of the TFT array (Nyquist frequency of ~3.93 mm-1 (127 micron pixel pitch).
CT
icon_mobile_dropdown
Three-dimensional NEQ transfer characteristics of volume CT using direct- and indirect-detection flat-panel imagers
Jeffrey H. Siewerdsen, David A. Jaffray
Foremost among the promising imaging performance characteristics of cone-beam CT using flat-panel imagers is the ability to form volumetric images with soft-tissue contrast visibility in combination with sub-millimeter 3-D spatial resolution. Each of these two essential characteristics is intimately related to the spatial-frequency-dependent signal and noise transfer characteristics of the imaging system. Therefore a thorough, quantitative analysis of the 3-D noise-equivalent quanta (NEQ) and detective quantum efficiency (DQE) is essential to understanding the volumetric imaging performance of such systems, identifying the factors that limit performance, and revealing their full potential. This paper presents investigation of the 3-D NEQ and DQE for volume CT systems based on direct and indirect-detection flat-panel imagers (FPIs). Classical descriptions of image noise in transaxial CT are extended to the case of non-ideal 2-D detectors and 3-D image reconstruction. Definitions of NEQ and DQE are extended to provide figures of merit for 3-D imaging performance. A complex interplay between the system transfer functions, 3-D noise aliasing, and the 3-D DQE is uncovered, revealing several important phenomena: (1) 3-D NPS aliasing is a significant factor in the reconstruction process affecting DQE; (2) the degree of 3-D NPS aliasing is different for direct and indirect-detection FPIs and is related in non-trivially to the detector MTF and reconstruction filter; (3) the 3-D NEQ depends significantly on the choice of reconstruction filter -- in contrast to the classical notion that NEQ is independent of such -- and the effect is wholly attributable to 3-D NPS aliasing; and (4) the 3-D DQE for volume reconstructions is asymmetric between transverse and sagittal/coronal planes. Results for 3-D NEQ and DQE are integrated with 3-D spatial-frequency-dependent descriptions of imaging task (e.g., ideal observer detection and/or discrimination tasks) to yield the 3-D detectability index, helping to bridge the gap between NEQ and the performance of model observers.
Three-dimensional reconstruction algorithm for a reverse geometry volumetric CT system with a large-array scanned source
We have proposed a CT system design to rapidly produce volumetric images with negligible cone beam artifacts. The investigated system uses a large array scanned source with a smaller array of fast detectors. The x-ray source is electronically steered across a 2D target every few milliseconds as the system rotates. The proposed reconstruction algorithm for this system is a modified 3D filtered backprojection method. The data are rebinned into 2D parallel ray projections, most of which are tilted with respect to the axis of rotation. Each projection is filtered with a 2D kernel and backprojected onto the desired image matrix. To ensure adequate spatial resolution and low artifact level, we rebin the data onto an array that has sufficiently fine spatial and angular sampling. Due to finite sampling in the real system, some of the rebinned projections will be sparse, but we hypothesize that the large number of views will compensate for the data missing in a particular view. Preliminary results using simulated data with the expected discrete sampling of the source and detector arrays suggest that high resolution (<0.5 mm in all directions) images can be obtained in a single rotation with the proposed system and reconstruction algorithm.
Analytical noise and slice-sensitivity-profile models for multislice helical CT
Multi-slice computed tomography (MSCT) is one of the most recent technological advancements in CT. Several experimental studies have been conducted in the last few years on the peformance of MSCT. However, there is a lack of theoretical analysis on the slice sensitivity profile (SSP) and noise performance. In this paper, we derive several closed-form expressions to characterize these performance parameters under different detector configurations and acquisition modes. Following the common practice, the expressions are explicitly described for regions near the iso-center, although the same approach can be used to describe system performances away from the iso-center. Our models are validated against phantom experiments.
Phase-contrast tomography and the local tomography problem
Phase-contrast tomography is a non-interferometric imaging technique for reconstructing the refractive index distribution of a weakly absorbing object from a set of tomographic projection measurements. In many practical situations, it is desirable to minimize the field of view (FOV) of the imaging system in order to increase the spatial resolution of the reconstructed image. When the object of interest is larger than the FOV, the measured projections are truncated and one is faced with a local tomography reconstruction problem. In this work, we investigate the local tomography problem for phase-contrast tomography and propose a simple algorithm for reconstructing image boundaries from untruncated and truncated phase-contrast projection data. Simulation studies are presented to corroborate our theoretical findings.
High-resolution video-based EPID for cone beam CT
Farhad A. Ghelmansarai, Ali R. Bani-Hashemi, Juan Carlos Celi, et al.
A high-resolution video (HRV) based EPID that is capable of matching the high spatial resolution and SNR (signal to noise ratio) of a-Si flat panel devices was developed at Siemens OCS (Oncology Care Systems) for cone beam CT. This system is using a high resolution CCD camera (1300 x 1030). The optical components and scintillator screen were modified to generate high-resolution images. A Pips-Pro QC3 phantom was used to compare the spatial resolution and the contrast to noise ratio (CNR) of a-Si flat panel (1024x1024) and HRV system. The QC phantom was placed at the linear accelerator iso-center, and the detectors were placed 40cm below iso-center. The measured f50 for the Siemens a-Si flat panel and HRV are 0.49 lp/mm, and 0.43 lp/mm; respectively. The image of the flat panel had already been corrected for Offset, Gain and Defective pixels; however, no correction was performed on the HRV system. Due to the fast readout of HRV, small pixel size, and adjustable camera lens aperture, a thicker scintillator screen would have resulted in an increase in SNR without sensor saturation during radiation treatment imaging. This is one of the main advantages of this system compared to the flat panels, and it makes the system ideal for cone beam reconstructions as well as regular therapy imaging. A new electronic readout is implemented in HRV control circuit that will synchronize the image acquisition with the linear accelerator, and thereby increases the SNR.
Breast Imaging I
icon_mobile_dropdown
Advantages of gridless full-field digital mammography
Kirsi Nykanen, Samuli Siltanen
The purpose of the study was to find out whether the image quality in full-field digital mammography can be improved while lowering the patient dose by removing the anti-scatter grid. Moreover, a fast approximate computational algorithm was developed for determining the scattered field in a real mammogram. The method is non-iterative, robust against noise, and works without modification for any scatter-to-primary ratio. Furthermore, it is computationally effective since it is based on fast Fourier transform (FFT). It was found out that the wide dynamic range of digital detectors leads to decrease in patient dose from 10.9% up to 46.6% at breast thickness of 2cm and from 0.8% up to 40.8% at breast thickness of 4cm depending on the efficiency of the removed grid. At constant patient dose the increase in contrast-to-noise ratio is 5.8% - 36.9% and 0.4%-30.0% accordingly at those two breast thickness. The convolution-based X-ray scatter model was considered. The developed scatter removal method was demonstrated with simulated mammograms and applied to clinical full-field digital mammograms acquired with a high-end digital flat panel detector based on amorphous selenium. Errors in reconstructed scattered fields were 0.3% in case of an ideal simulated mammogram and 7.4% in case of a real simulated mammogram (3cm breast). Applications where the scattered field needs to be determined include 3-D mammography and dual-energy breast imaging. In screening mammography gray-scale optimization eliminates the effect of scattering.
Optimal radiographic techniques for digital mammograms obtained with an amorphous selenium detector
Traditional film/screen mammograms are obtained using Molybdenum or Rhodium target x-ray tubes. The energy spectrum from these sources matches the limited latitude of film/screen systems. For digital imaging systems, the latitude is linear over a wide range of exposures and arbitrary H&D curves can be obtained with image processing. This allows the recorded contrast to noise ratio (CNR) to be optimized by considering a wide range of radiographic techniques. For this work, we modeled the radiographic process for a digital (amorphous selenium) mammography system. The optimal CNR relative to dose was determined for several target/filter combinations, for a wide range of kVp values, and for varying breast thickness. The target/filter combinations included: Mo/Mo, Mo/Rh, Rh/Rh, W/Al, W/Mo, W/Ag, and W/Sn. As breast thickness increased, the use of a tungsten target with a tin filter resulted in a 34% improvement in CNR for the same dose to the breast when compared to the use of a Molybdenum target with a Molybdenum filter. Notably, the W/Sn target/filter combination resulted in a significantly lower mA-s for the same breast dose (2/3 to 1/5 lower for a breast thickness from 4 to 8cm). In mammography applications, use of a Tungsten tube rather than the traditional Molybdenum tube should lead to significant reductions in exposure time and tube heat while maintaining similar image quality and dose.
Characterization of a direct full-field flat-panel digital mammography detector
Our work is to investigate the imaging performance of a direct, full-field prototype digital mammography detector as a function of x-ray exposure and detector operational conditions for digital mammography and advanced applications such as tomosynthesis. Theoretical and experimental methods previously developed for the study of small-area prototype detectors have been applied to the investigation of spatial frequency dependent detective quantum efficiency [DQE(f)] of the full-field prototype detector, which has 2816 x 2048 pixels with 85 μm pixel size. The focus of our study is the impact of scaling up the detector design on imaging performance, e.g. electronic noise, readout rate and image artifacts. The results showed that DQE(f) of the full-field detectors is in the same range as that measured from the small-area prototype detector, both of which are superior to existing technologies based on indirect detection. However DQE(f) drops more rapidly than the small-area prototype as exposure decreases, which is to be expected from the higher electronic noise of the full-field detector. Lag and ghosting, both of which can introduce image artifacts, were studied at typical screening mammography image intervals. The effect of lag can be eliminated with frequent update of the offset images. Ghosting at x-ray dose equivalent to a single view mammogram is negligible.
Evaluation of novel direct- and indirect-detection active matrix flat-panel imagers (AMFPIs) for mammography
Youcef El-Mohri, Larry E. Antonuk, Kyung-Wook Jee, et al.
A performance evaluation of small-area, high-spatial-resolution, active matrix flat-panel imager (AMFPI) prototypes, operated under mammographic conditions, is reported. These prototypes are based on two 512 x 512 pixel imagers employing novel designs to enhance signal performance for direct and indirect detection. The indirect detection prototype is based on a 75 μm pixel pitch array incorporating a continuous photodiode design, as opposed to the discrete photodiode design used in conventional flat-panel imagers. This array was coupled to a pair of commercially-available x-ray converters: (1) a 34 mg/cm2 Gd2O2S:Tb phosphor screen (Min-R, Kodak) and (2) a 150 μm thick structured CsI:Tl scintillator on a fiber-optic plate (FOS-HL, Hamamatsu). The direct detection prototype is based on a 100 μm pixel pitch array and uses a 240 μm thick, high gain mercuric iodide (HgI2) photoconductor. Measurements of sensitivity, MTF, NPS and DQE were performed with a 26 kVp mammography beam attenuated by a 4 cm BR-12 breast phantom at various radiation exposures. Results from empirical studies of sensitivity indicate that these imagers offer a substantial enhancement in signal over conventional flat-panel imagers. Measurements of DQE for the imagers show values greater than those obtained from high performance mammographic film-screen systems, under some conditions. These studies also show that the FOS-HL imager configuration despite its lower MTF, exhibits DQE performance (up to approximately 0.77) superior or equivalent to that of the Min-R configuration due to better optical properties of the converter. In addition, despite a smaller pixel pitch, both of these indirect detection configurations exhibit improved DQE in comparison to similar configurations employing a 97 μm pitch discrete photodiode design, especially at low exposures. Results of DQE measurements from the HgI2 photoconductor prototype are promising (DQE values up to approximately 0.6). Finally, calculations of potential DQE performance for hypothetical 50 μm pitch imagers, employing similar novel designs, were performed. These calculations were based on the cascaded systems formalism and used realistic inputs derived from empirical measurements. The results predict that the HgI2 configuration would provide high DQE performance (up to approximately 0.9), which would be largely unaffected by the magnitude of exposure, due to the high gain of the photoconductor. These calculations also indicate that the continuous photodiode configuration would provide high DQE (up to approximately 0.8), degraded only at low exposure by the effect of additive noise.
Real-time flat-panel detector-based cone beam volume CT breast imaging: phantom and specimen study
Ruola Ning, David L. Conover, Yong Yu, et al.
Conventional film-screen mammography is the most effective tool for the early detection of breast cancer currently available. However, conventional mammography has relatively low sensitivity to detect small breast cancers (under several millimeters) owing to an overlap in the appearances of benign and malignant lesions, and surrounding structure. The limitations accompanying conventional mammography is to be addressed by incorporating a cone beam volume CT imaging technique with a recently developed flat panel detector. Computer simulation and preliminary studies have been performed to prove the feasibility of developing a flat panel detector-based cone beam volume CT breast imaging (FPD-CBVCTBI) technique. In this study, a specimen experiment is performed to confirm the findings in the computer simulation and previous phantom studies using the current prototype cone beam volume CT scanner. The results indicate that the CBVCTBI technique effectively removes structure overlap and significantly improves the detectability of small breast tumors. More importantly, the results also demonstrate CBVCTBI offers good correlation with pathology images with the radiation dose level less than or equal to that of conventional mammography. The results from this study suggest that FPD-CBVCTBI is a potentially powerful breast-imaging tool.
Full-field images of mammographic phantoms obtained with a single photon counting system
Salvator Roberto Amendolia, Maria Giuseppina Bisogni, Pasquale Delogu, et al.
As the use of digital radiographic equipment in the morphological imaging field is becoming largely diffuse, the research of new and more performing devices from public institutions and industrial companies is in constant progress. Many of these devices are based on solid-state detectors as X-ray sensors. Semiconductor pixel detectors, originally developed in the high energy physics environment, have been then proposed as digital detector for medical imaging applications. In this paper a digital single photon counting device, based on silicon and GaAs pixel detectors, is presented. The detector is a thin slab of semiconductor crystal equipped with an array of 64 by 64 square contacts, 170-μm side. The data read-out is performed by a VLSI integrated circuit named Photon Counting Chip (PCC), developed within the MEDIPIX collaboration. Each chip cell geometrically matches the sensor pixel. It contains a charge preamplifier, a threshold comparator and a 15 bits pseudo-random counter and it is coupled to the detector by means of bump-bonding. Most important advantages of such a system, with respect to a traditional X-rays film/screen device, are the wider linear dynamic range (3x104) and the higher performance in terms of MTF and DQE. Electronics read-out performance as well as imaging capabilities of the digital device will be presented. Images of mammographic phantoms acquired with a standard mammographic tube will be compared with radiographs obtained with traditional film/screen systems.
X-Ray Detectors II
icon_mobile_dropdown
Image quality of digital radiography using flat detector technology
Thierry Ducourant, David Couder, Thibaut Wirth, et al.
One of the most demanding applications in dynamic X-Ray imaging is Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA). As opposed to other applications such as Radiography or Fluoroscopy, there has been so far limited attempts to introduce DSA with flat detector (FD) technology: Up to now, only part of the very demanding requirements could be taken into account. In order to enable an introduction of FD technology also in this area, a complete understanding of all physical phenomena related to the use of this technology in DSA is necessary. This knowledge can be used for detector design and performance optimization. Areas of research include fast switching between several detector operating modes (e.g. switching between fluoroscopy and high dose exposure modes and vice versa) and non stability during the DSA run e.g. due to differences in gain between subsequent images. Furthermore, effects of local and global X-Ray overexposure (due to direct radiation), which can cause temporal artifacts such as ghosting, may have a negative impact on the image quality. Pixel shift operations and image subtraction enhance the visibility of any artifact. The use of a refresh light plays an important role in the optimization process. Both an 18x18 cm2 as well as a large area 30x40 cm2 flat panel detector are used for studying the various phenomena. Technical measurements were obtained using complex imaging sequences representing the most demanding application conditions. Studies on subtraction test objects were performed and vascular applications have been carried out in order to confirm earlier findings. The basis for comparison of DSA is, still, the existing and mature IITV technology. The results of this investigation show that the latest generation of dynamic flat detectors is capable of handling this kind of demanding application. Not only the risk areas and their solutions and points of attention will be addressed, but also the benefits of present FD technology with respect to state-of-the-art IITV technology regarding DSA will be discussed.
Development and evaluation of a digital radiography system using a large-area flat panel detector
Shigeyuki Ikeda, Katsumi Suzuki, Ken Ishikawa, et al.
We developed prototype Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA) System with a new large area FPD. Dynamic range, MTF, Contrast ratio and line noise were much improved. The improved FPD is a scintillator-type detector, and has a 40 x 30 cm active area, 2048 x 1536 matrix with 194um pixel pitch. The Prototype DSA system has two x-ray detectors, the FPD and the I.I.-CCD camera, and we can choose them on demand. All images captured from both detectors at 3 frames/sec in DSA mode and 30 frames/sec in Fluoroscopy mode are forwarded to our image-processing unit. We applied the new DSA system to more than 150 studies and compared the results with images from the I.I.-CCD. In DSA mode, FPD System, which has a wide dynamic range, large detecting area, and good contrast ratio yielded superior angiogram images compared with the I.I-CCD system. In Fluoroscopy mode, we improved line noise and increased the contrast of catheters and guide wires with a new image processing technique. With these improvements, the image quality of the FPD System is superior to the I.I.-CCD system at the exposure range of over 2uR/frame (17.4 nGy/frame).
Imaging performance of an amorphous selenium flat-panel detector for digital fluoroscopy
Dylan C. Hunt, Olivier Tousignant, Yves Demers, et al.
The imaging performance of a 34.5 x 34.5 cm2 direct conversion flat-panel detector with a 1 mm thick amorphous selenium layer was measured over the fluoroscopic exposure range (0.56 - 10.8 μR/frame). The pixels measured 300 x 300 μm. Measurements of the modulation transfer function (MTF), the noise power spectrum (NPS), and the detective quantum efficiency (DQE) were made. By comparing the MTF to the sinc function the measured effective fill factor of the active matrix was determined to be almost 100%. The electronic noise of the active matrix was measured and found to be 3800 electrons. The DQE(f) was found to be better than the expected sinc2 function. This was due to the presence of a pre-sampling blur identified as charge trapping at an interface in the a-Se layers. At the highest exposure investigated, the DQE(0) was found to be less than the quantum efficiency and the difference was ascribed to a combination of the electronic noise, a small drop in sensitivity due to the charge trapping blur, and incomplete charge collection.
Back-illuminated photodiodes for multislice CT
Randy P. Luhta, Rodney A. Mattson, Narayan Taneja, et al.
Conventional 2D photodiodes used in multislice CT detectors impose a limitation on the number of slices that can be achieved. The limitations encountered are in the number of metal lines that can be run between photodiode elements without significantly reducing the photodiode active area and in the density of wirebonds that can be accomodated at the edge of the chip. In addition, the photodiodes cannot easily be tiled in two directions due to the need for wirebonding on at least one edge. We have developed a 2D back illuminated photodiode array for multislice CT that overcomes the above limitations. The light sensitivity, sensitivity profiles, risetime, crosstalk, linearity and shunt resistance of the back illuminated photodiodes have been evaluated. The results show that these parameters either meet or exceed the specifications required for CT. The back illuminated photodiode represents an enabling technology for truly large area CT detection systems.
Flat detector with integrated dose sensing
Michael Overdick, Ronald A. Ford, Anthony R. Franklin, et al.
Integrated dose sensing in Flat Detectors allows a during pulse control of the X-ray illumination without the need for external dose sensing devices. Standard designs of Flat Detectors do not allow during pulse dose sensing since the information is collected from the pixels only in the read-out phase after the X-ray illumination. This paper introduces a special detector plate design for obtaining dose sensing information directly from the X-ray detector while the X-ray pulse is being applied. This dose sensing information is read at a lower spatial resolution than the actual X-ray image but with a sub-millisecond temporal resolution. The dose sensing operates without any additional radiation burden on the patient and without attenuation of the image information. Experimental results from a small area (4x4 cm2) detector are presented, including an analysis of noise, linearity and cross-talk.
Novel Imaging Methods
icon_mobile_dropdown
Coherent scatter computed tomography: a novel medical imaging technique
Jens-Peter Schlomka, Adrian Harding, Udo van Stevendaal, et al.
Fan-beam coherent scatter computed tomography (CSCT) is a novel X-ray based imaging method revealing structural information of tissue under investigation. The source of contrast is the angular-dependent coherent scatter cross-section, which is determined by the molecular structure. In this work a phantom consisting of water, tricalcium phosphate, collagen and fat was used to investigate the contrast resolution of these four tissue constituents. Scatter projections were measured in fan-beam 3rd generation CT-geometry using an experimental demonstrator set-up equipped with a 4.5 kW DC power X-ray tube and photon-counting detectors. Reconstruction was performed using two algorithms, one based on algebraic reconstruction technique (ART) and the other based on filtered back-projection (FBP). The reconstruction results of the two techniques are compared. Furthermore, scatter functions of the four components were extracted from the 3D data sets and compared to previous measurements. The applicability of this technique for medical diagnosis is discussed.
Evaluation of two phase contrast techniques: diffraction-enhanced imaging and propagation
Stefan Fiedler, Elodie Pagot, Peter Cloetens, et al.
Two X-ray phase-contrast imaging techniques are compared in a quantitative way for future mammographic applications: Diffraction Enhanced Imaging (DEI) and Propagation. The first uses an analyzer crystal after the sample acting as an angular filter for X-rays refracted by the sample. The latter simply uses the propagation (Fresnel diffraction) of the monochromatic and partially coherent X-ray beam over large distances. Experiments to compare both modalities have been performed at the Topography Beamline of the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility. The respective set-ups and experimental parameters are described in detail. Depending on the object properties, the two techniques present a difference in area contrast and edge visibility. DEI shows an enhancement of area contrast for positions of the crystal corresponding to the tails of its rocking curve (RC) and a similar increase but inverted is also visible at the peak of its RC. At the tails, the contrast is mainly produced by ultra small angle scattering, at the peak, it is due to absorption and scatter rejection by the analyzer. At the flanks, it may disappear when attenuation and scattering effects compensate each other. However, an enhancement of the object edges is clearly noticeable, which mainly corresponds to the refracted part. Propagation reveals an improvement of the edge visibility with the distance and shows negligible area contrast for non-absorbing, large structures.
On the possibility of utilizing scattering-based contrast agents in combination with diffraction-enhanced imaging
Preliminary experiments have been carried out in order to evaluate the potential of the Diffraction Enhanced Imaging (DEI) technique in combination with contrast agents not based on X-ray absorption properties, but that provide strong scattering signals. The contrast agents tested in this study are microbubble echo-enhancing agents, usually used in ultrasound examinations, which are completely invisible with conventional X-ray absorption techniques. A DEI set-up has been implemented at the Medical Beamline at the synchrotron radiation facility ELETTRA (Trieste, Italy). The analyzer crystal is a single flat silicon crystal utilized in the [111] reflection. By shifting the analyzer crystal to different positions of the rocking curve it is possible to detect the scattered photons; in particular, if the sample consists of a large number of particles with size smaller than the pixel size of the detector, an overall effect can be visualized. Phantoms containing ultrasound contrast agents have been built and imaged at different angular positions of the analyzer crystal at 17 keV and 25 keV. For all the phantoms a much stronger contrast has been measured in comparison to the contrast evaluated from the images produced with normal absorption methods.
Bi-plane correlation imaging for improved detection of lung nodules
Bi-plane correlation imaging (BCI) is a new imaging approach that utilizes angular information from a bi-plane digital acquisition in conjunction with computer assisted detection (CAD) to reduce the degrading influence of anatomical noise in the detection of subtle lesions in planar images. An anthropomorphic chest phantom, supplemented with added nodule phantoms (5-13 mm at the image plane), was imaged from different posterior projections within a ±12° range by moving the x-ray tube vertically and horizontally with respect to the detector. Each image was analyzed using a basic front-end single-view CAD algorithm. The correlation of the suspect lesions from the PA view with those from each of the oblique views was examined using a priori knowledge of the acquisition geometry. The correlated suspect lesions were registered as positive. Using an optimum --3° vertical geometry and processing parameters, BCI resulted in 62.5% sensitivity, 1.5 FP/image, and 0.885 PPV. The corresponding values from the observer experiment were 56% sensitivity, 10.8 FP/image, and 0.45 PPV, respectively. Compared to single-view CAD results, the BCI reduced sensitivity by 20%. However, the corresponding reduction in FPs was notably higher (94%) leading to 140% improvement in the PPV. Changes in processing parameters could result in higher PPV and lower FP/image at the expense of lower sensitivity. Similar findings were indicated for small (5-9 mm) and large (9-13 mm) nodules, but the relative improvement was significantly higher for smaller nodules. (The research was supported by a grant from the NIH, R21CA91806.)
Calcification content quantification by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry with a 2D digital radiographic detector
Jean Marc Dinten, Christine Robert-Coutant, Michel Darboux, et al.
In a previous paper (SPIE Medical Imaging 2001), a dual energy method for bone densitometry using a 2D digital radiographic detector has been presented. In this paper, calcium content quantification performance of the approach is precised. The main challenge is to achieve quantification using scatter-corrected dual energy acquisitions. Therefore a scatter estimation approach, based on an expression of scatter as a functional of the primary flux, has been developed. This expression is derived from the Klein and Nishina equation and includes tabulated scatter level values. The calcium quantification performances are validated on two configurations. A first one is issued from criteria developed by the French “Groupe de Recherche et d'Information sur les Osteoporoses.” It is based on the use of a phantom made of five 3mm thick PVC sheets in the form of five steps, representing five different bone mineral density values, included in a lucite container filled with water. Additional lucite plates can be put over the phantom. This phantom has been used for evaluation of quantification robustness versus patient thickness and composition variations, and for accuracy evaluation. The second configuration, composed of small calcified objects (representative of lung nodules), is used for evaluating capacities to differentiate calcified from non calcified nodules and to test calcium content quantification performance.
Simulation of trabecular bone sample x-ray microradiography
Joachim Tabary, Jean Marc Dinten, Regis Guillemaud, et al.
Osteoporosis is a disease characterized by a decrease of bone mineral density as well as by architecture modification leading to an increase of fracture risk. This paper is part of study investigating the possibility to extract some structural parameters quantifying trabecular bone architecture from radiographies realized in vivo. The first step of the study is the definition of optimum radiographic conditions (X-ray spectrum, detector) as well as the development of adapted image processing tools to extract relevant indexes characterizing architecture. Therefore a simulation process computing synthetic radiographies from trabecular bone samples has been developed. This process is done in three distinct steps: (1) Computation of a very high spatial resolution 3D μCT volume of a human trabecular bone sample from a series of acquisitions with a microtomography system using synchrotron radiation. (2) Transformation of the μCT volume in a materials voxel volume. (3) Simulation of the radiography projection by using the X-ray radiographic simulation software Sindbad. The simulation software provides a lot of parameters which can be easily modified (spectra, materials, geometry, detector...) so that its use for an optimisation purpose is very practical. Comparison of simulated and experimental radiographies performed under synchrotron radiation microtomography configuration validates the accuracy of our simulation process. Simulated radiographs under several clinical conditions are also presented.
Breast Imaging II
icon_mobile_dropdown
Effect on DQE of screen energy weighting in mammography
Our work investigates the effect on the zero-spatial-frequency DQE of indirect mammographic image receptors of the combined effects of x-ray beam hardening and light photon transport within the x-ray sensitive medium of the image receptor. Beam hardening, in this context, refers to the preferential absorption of low-energy x-ray photons at the surface of the detector on which the x-ray beam is incident, with deeper layers of the detector absorbing higher and higher average energies. The light photon transport properties of both powder and crystalline/columnar phosphors favor the collection at the light-sensitive element of the detector of light photons generated closest to that element. The net result of these two effects is to perform a weighting of the detected x-ray spectrum. For the standard back-screen configuration used in conventional mammography, low-energy x rays are more heavily weighted, matching the energy dependence of the signal to be detected. For a front-screen configuration, used in all existing indirect-detection digital mammographic systems, just the opposite is true. We have used the optical Monte Carlo simulation code DETECT-II to determine average light collection efficiency and optical pulse distributions for a Min-R screen in both front- and back-screen configurations, and for two thicknesses of CsI, as a function of x-ray energy. These data, along with appropriately hardened x-ray spectra for several anode and filter combinations and a range of tube voltages, were used as input to the task-dependent DQE theory of Tapiovaara and Wagner.
Statistical properties of 4000 raw and processed digital mammograms from a GE Senograph 2000D
Aili K. Bloomquist, Martin J. Yaffe, Gordon E. Mawdsley, et al.
Optimization of the display of digital mammograms is an important challenge and requires knowledge of the characteristics of actual patient images. This work aims to create a description of some of the fundamental statistical properties of a large volume of images acquired on an FDA approved device as used in clinical practice. 4569 digital mammograms (1246 patients) were acquired between October 2001 and August 2002 on a GE Senograph 2000D at Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre. Images were saved in "raw" format. The breast was then segmented from the background on the image using a technique based on thresholding and some connectivity rules. The histogram of pixel values in the breast only is then calculated for both the raw and processed versions of the image. The region of constant thickness, where the breast is in contact with the compression paddle, was also segmented from the CC view raw images. The histogram and statistical properties in this central region were also calculated. Assorted statistical descriptors of the histograms were examined (dynamic range, mean, standard deviations, median and mode). The effect of image processing on the dynamic range in the periphery and central area of the breast was evaluated. The results were compared against the automatic exposure algorithm and acquisition parameters, projection (view) and breast thickness.
Controlling gray-level variation in contrast-enhanced digital mammography: design of a calibration procedure
Ideally, the gray level changes in a Contrast-Enhanced Digital Mammography (CEDM) sequence reflect the uptake and wash-out of contrast medium in the breast. While insignificant in standard mammography, gray level variations with time caused both by patient and system related factors, have been observed in clinical CEDM sequences. We have acquired phantom image series on digital mammography systems using a Mo/Cu anode-filter combination and a tube voltage between 45 and 49 kVp, in order to derive a model for gray level change with time as a function of system parameters. The gray level variation exhibits a fair degree of inter-series repeatability, and strongly depends on the dose received by the detector and timing of the image acquisition series. Moreover, for tissue-equivalent compositions, the relative gray level change with respect to the first image does not depend on the composition. We designed a calibration procedure that can be used to compensate for the tiny system-dependent signal variation that has been observed. A global reduction of 80-93% of the variation has been demonstrated in sequences acquired on a breast shaped phantom. Local improvement is effective across the whole field of view. When imaging iodine inserts (0.5-2 mg/cm2 concentration), the calibration increases the constancy with time of iodine signal on subtracted sequences by a factor of 4 (median value).
Computer simulation of CT mammography using a flat-panel imager
Software has been developed to simulate a cone-beam CT mammography imaging system that consists of an x-ray tube and a flat-panel detector that rotate simultaneously around the pendant breast. The simulation uses an analytical expression or ray-tracing to generate projection sets of breast phantoms at 1 keV intervals dictated by the input x-ray energy spectra. The x-ray focal spot was modeled as having a Gaussian distribution. The detector was modeled as an amorphous silicon (aSi:H) flat-panel imager that uses a structured CsI scintillator. Noise propagation through the detector was simulated by modeling statistical variations of the projection images at each energy interval as a scaled Poisson process. Scintillator blurring was simulated by using an empirically determined modulation transfer function. After introducing noise and detector blur, projection sets simulated at each energy were then combined and reconstructed using Feldkamp's cone-beam reconstruction algorithm. Using this framework, the effects of a number of acquisition and reconstruction parameters can be investigated. Some examples are shown including the impact of the kVp setting and the number of projection angles on the reconstructed image.
Volume Imaging - US/Tomosynthesis
icon_mobile_dropdown
Improved 3D reconstructions for generalized tomosynthesis
Paul F. Hemler, Stephen B. Robinson
This paper describes a unique system for constructing a three-dimensional volume from a set of two-dimensional (2D) x-ray projection images based on optical aperture theory. This proprietary system known as Tuned-Aperture Computed Tomography (TACT) is novel in that only a small number of projections acquired from arbitrary or task-specific projection angles is required for the reconstruction process. We used TACT to reconstruct a simulated phantom from seven 2D projections made with the x-ray source positioned within 30 degrees of perpendicular to a detector array. The distance from the x-ray source was also varied to change the amount of perspective distortion in each projection. Finally, we determined the reconstruction accuracy of TACT and compared it to that of a conventional tomosynthesis system. We found the reconstructed volumetric data sets computed with TACT to be geometrically accurate and contain significantly less visible blurring than a similar data set computed with the control technique.
Fast tomosynthesis for lung cancer detection using the SBDX geometry
Rebecca Fahrig, Angel R. Pineda, Edward G. Solomon, et al.
Radiology-based lung-cancer detection is a high-contrast imaging task, consisting of the detection of a small mass of tissue within much lower density lung parenchyma. This imaging task requires removal of confounding image details, fast image acquisition (< 0.1 s for pericardial region), low dose (comparable to a chest x-ray), high resolution (< 0.25 mm in-plane) and patient positioning flexibility. We present an investigation of tomosynthesis, implemented using the Scanning-Beam Digital X-ray System (SBDX), to achieve these goals. We designed an image-based computer model of tomosynthesis using a high-resolution (0.15-mm isotropic voxels), low-noise CT volume image of a lung phantom, numerically added spherical lesions and convolution-based tomographic blurring. Lesion visibility was examined as a function of half-tomographic angle for 2.5 and 4.0 mm diameter lesions. Gaussian distributed noise was added to the projected images. For lesions 2.5 mm and 4.0 mm in diameter, half-tomographic angles of at least 6° and 9° respectively were necessary before visualization of the lesions improved. The addition of noise for a dose equivalent to 1/10 that used for a standard chest radiograph did not significantly impair lesion detection. The results are promising, indicating that lung-cancer detection using a modified SBDX system is possible.
Practical strategies for the clinical implementation of matrix inversion tomosynthesis (MITS)
Digital tomosynthesis is a method that enables the retroactive reconstruction of arbitrary tomographic planes in an object from a finite series of digital projection radiographs, acquired with limited angle tube movement. Conventional tomosynthesis suffers from the presence of blurring artifacts, created by objects located outside of each reconstructed plane. Matrix inversion tomosynthesis (MITS) utilizes known acquisition geometry to solve directly for the unwanted out-of-plane blur artifacts, thus enabling their removal. This paper examines practical strategies for the implementation of MITS in a clinical setting, on a flat-panel fast-readout detector, with the aim of minimizing procedure time and image reconstruction artifacts concurrently. Topics include a comparison of continuous vs. incremental tube motion, the presence of reconstruction artifacts due to error in computing the x-ray tube location, the effect of scrubbing the detector between projections to reduce image retention, and a method for accounting for data that gets projected off the detector. We conclude that MITS is robust enough to be clinically applicable, even under less-than-ideal conditions. Rapid image acquisition with continuous tube movement and no detector scrubbing is clinically desirable for MITS imaging of the chest, where patient motion is a concern. Knowledge of the source-detector geometry can be satisfactorily determined via either a lead fiducial marker placed on the patient, or a tube motion device with sufficient precision and accuracy. Extrapolation of data at the top and bottom of projection images provides excellent amelioration of image truncation artifacts.
Generalized NEQ for assessment of ultrasound image quality
An information-theoretic framework for assessing and predicting ultrasound system performance for detection tasks is outlined. Current models of image quality for ultrasound detection tasks make some stringent assumptions, including large target area, that place limits on the applicability of the theory. New models of image quality for ultrasound systems are proposed based on the ideal observer that account for noise, system, and object properties. One result is an expression for the ideal observer detectability that is a generalization of Noise-Equivalent Quanta (NEQ), a measure used by photon imaging modalities. The detection signal-to-noise ratio is shown to be an integration of the generalized NEQ weighted by the spectral variance of the target signal (in contrast to the squared magnitude of the Fourier transform of the signal, as is the case with other modalities). This reflects that ultrasound systems are sensitive not to the magnitude of the medium parameters but rather the variance (spatial fluctuations) of these quantities. The resulting framework is amenable to measurement and prediction of system performance. The theory is used to predict the information content of the ultrasonic beam at various field points. New strategies are revealed for processing RF data that could improve detection of lesions.
Automated assessment of small airway disease from low-dose lung CT: a preliminary study
Bjorn Dittmer-Roche, Henry Rusinek, Jane P. Ko, et al.
Air trapping is a prominent finding in small airway disease (SAD) of the lungs. To investigate the feasibility of accurate, automated assessment of air-trapping from low-dose CT, we compare visual scoring by expert radiologists to a conventional method of automated assessment as well as two novel methods. The conventional method, the "density mask" method, has been reported to correlate weakly but significantly with visual scoring on normal-dose CT. While we were unable to reproduce these results on our low-dose scans, our two novel methods showed some promise. More study on larger data sets is required to determine the optimal analysis method.
Imaging Physics II
icon_mobile_dropdown
End-to-end linearity considerations for photon-limited detection and display systems
End-to-end system studies in the digital acquisition of photon-limited images inevitably lead to the question of setting technical design goals in order to achieve overall linearity. But this itself poses the specific question of which key print/display variables should, in ideal circumstances, be linear with which key scene-acquisition parameters. Within the digital context, intuitive answers gleaned from traditional analog approaches to this question can vary from the confusing to the misleading, and digital attempts at direct emulation of analog systems may in fact off-set the potential advantages implicit in the newer digital technologies. The author has used a digital end-to-end signal-to-noise ratio model to consider some aspects of this linearity question, and to offer solutions based on the combination of SNR optimization appropriate during image acquisition, and the human visual-response characteristics appropriate during display. Some results and conclusions are discussed here, especially those relating to the optimum digital strategy for scene-acquisition.
Measurement of the noise components in the medical x-ray intensity pattern due to overlaying nonrecognizable structures
Oleg Tischenko, Christoph Hoeschen, Olaf Effenberger M.D., et al.
There are many aspects that influence and deteriorate the detection of pathologies in X-ray images. Some of those are due to effects taking place in the stage of forming the X-ray intensity pattern in front of the x-ray detector. These can be described as motion blurring, depth blurring, anatomical background, scatter noise and structural noise. Structural noise results from an overlapping of fine irrelevant anatomical structures. A method for measuring the combined effect of structural noise and scatter noise was developed and will be presented in this paper. This method is based on the consideration that within a pair of projections created after rotation of the object with a small angle (which is within the typical uncertainty in positioning the patient) both images would show the same relevant structures whereas the projection of the fine overlapping structures will appear quite differently in the two images. To demonstrate the method two X-ray radiographs of a lung phantom were produced. The second radiograph was achieved after rotating the lung by an angle of about 3. Dyadic wavelet representations of both images were regarded. For each value of the wavelet scale parameter the corresponding pair of approximations was matched using the cross correlation matching technique. The homologous regions of approximations were extracted. The image containing only those structures that appear in both images simultaneously was then reconstructed from the wavelet coefficients corresponding to the homologous regions. The difference between one of the original images and the noise-reduced image contains the structural noise and the scatter noise.
Bar-pattern technique for modulation transfer function measurement in portal imaging
The modulation transfer function (MTF) is a fundamental measure of spatial resolution of an imaging system, and can be measured by imaging a slit, edge or a bar-pattern. In portal imaging, the MTF has been measured using the slit and edge techniques, requiring very thick collimation to minimize the effect of megavoltage scatter and laborious alignment procedures. A simpler and quicker method for measuring MTF is presented: the bar-pattern. This method has been successfully used in diagnostic imaging. In portal imaging, this method is sensitive to the measurement of MTF(0) due to lateral scattering of megavoltage x-rays. A lack of a precise measurement of MTF(0) can lead to an over-estimation of MTF. The slit and bar-pattern techniques were studied using Monte Carlo simulations on a kinestatic charge detector (KCD), which uses a slot photon beam and a scanning high-pressure gas multi-ion chamber. The experimental condition for measuring MTF(0) was determined. MTF measurements using the slit and bar techniques, as well as those from Monte Carlo simulations, were subsequently observed to be in good agreement (i.e. one standard deviation of measurement). The bar-pattern method, being easier and simpler than the slit or edge techniques, provides a fast MTF measurement.
Overall x-ray system simulation model developed for system design and image quality versus patient dose optimization
We have developed a full-scale image quality (IQ) simulation model as a tool for X-ray system design, image quality optimization and patient dose reduction. The IQ model supports the (de-)composition of system level requirements and simulates several types of automatic X-ray control technique. The model is implemented in LabVIEW. The X-ray system is modeled in distinguishable components and processes, which allows isolation of sub-systems and exclusion of devices. All relevant patient dose and IQ items such as contrast, sharpness, lag and noise are calculated and additionally combined in IQ "figures of merit" (FOM). Some characteristic application examples will be presented: In a general image magnification study we compare magnification techniques, such as geometric enlargement, image intensifier zooming and digital processing. In an optimization study we apply a new IQ FOM that contains not only imaging properties of the system, but also detail information in terms of material, size and thickness. Combining the IQ simulation model with a Pareto trade-off algorithm appears to be a promising optimization approach. In addition to the mentioned employment, the IQ simulation model is also suitable for comparison studies on the performance of flat detectors versus image intensifier television detectors, application related studies and fine tuning of specific settings and adjustments, design of test objects and development of measuring methods.
Optical properties of tissue measured using terahertz-pulsed imaging
Elizabeth Berry, Anthony J. Fitzgerald, Nickolay N. Zinov'ev, et al.
The first demonstrations of terahertz imaging in biomedicine were made several years ago, but few data are available on the optical properties of human tissue at terahertz frequencies. A catalogue of these properties has been established to estimate variability and determine the practicality of proposed medical applications in terms of penetration depth, image contrast and reflection at boundaries. A pulsed terahertz imaging system with a useful bandwidth 0.5-2.5 THz was used. Local ethical committee approval was obtained. Transmission measurements were made through tissue slices of thickness 0.08 to 1 mm, including tooth enamel and dentine, cortical bone, skin, adipose tissue and striated muscle. The mean and standard deviation for refractive index and linear attenuation coefficient, both broadband and as a function of frequency, were calculated. The measurements were used in simple models of the transmission, reflection and propagation of terahertz radiation in potential medical applications. Refractive indices ranged from 1.5 ± 0.5 for adipose tissue to 3.06 ± 0.09 for tooth enamel. Significant differences (P < 0.05) were found between the broadband refractive indices of a number of tissues. Terahertz radiation is strongly absorbed in tissue so reflection imaging, which has lower penetration requirements than transmission, shows promise for dental or dermatological applications.
Noninvasive quantitative mapping of conductivity and dielectric distributions using RF wave propagation effects in high-field MRI
Han Wen
In this paper I show with phantom and animal experiments a non-invasive and quantitative method for measuring the conductivity and dielectric distributions based on high field magnetic resonance imaging. High field MRI is accompanied by significant RF wave propagation effects. They are observed as phase and magnitude variations of the image that cannot be removed by optimizing the static field homogeneity, or by improving the RF coils. These variations reflect the RF field distribution in the sample, and in fact obey a modified Helmholtz equation. By mapping both the phase and magnitude of the field with MRI techniques, both the conductivity and the dielectric constant are determined non-invasively. In phantom experiments at 1.5 tesla, conductivity values were measured at 4 mm resolution to 0.5 S/m accuracy. At 4.7 tesla, the accuracy was improved to 0.2 S/m, and the dielectric constant was measured to an accuracy of 5 (relative to vacuum) for 2cm regions.
X-Ray Detectors III
icon_mobile_dropdown
Exploring new frontiers in x-ray quantum limited portal imaging using active matrix flat-panel imagers (AMFPIs)
Amit R. Sawant, Larry E. Antonuk, Youcef El-Mohri, et al.
In recent years, indirect detection active matrix flat-panel imagers (AMFPIs) have become the gold standard in radiotherapy imaging. The excellent imaging performance of AMFPI-based electronic portal imaging devices (EPIDs) can be attributed to their ability to perform x-ray quantum limited imaging under radiotherapy conditions. However, all current commercial (AMFPI and non-AMFPI) EPIDs use only approximately 1% to 2% of the incident radiation. In this work, strategies to significantly improve the overall performance of indirect detection AMFPI-based EPIDs through novel designs, are presented. Specifically, the focus of this work is on thick, structured scintillators, which achieve high x-ray detection efficiency while simultaneously maintaining spatial resolution. Fundamental signal and noise measurements using prototype, small area, structured scintillators are reported. In addition, theoretical calculations were performed in order to estimate the signal and noise properties of various structured scintillator configurations. Results from theory and experiments were used to estimate the frequency-dependent detective quantum efficiency (DQE). Results suggest that these designs could yield DQE values that are significantly higher than those for current commercial EPID technologies.
Performance of prototype modules of a novel multislice CT detector based on CMOS photosensors
Lothar Spies, Francisco Morales, Roger Steadman, et al.
A novel CT detector based on CMOS photodiodes has been developed. A detector module comprises two identical photosensor arrays mounted to a ceramic substrate. Each sensor has a matrix of 20 by 10 pixels. Pixels are 1 mm (channel direction) x 1.8 mm (slice) large and consist of a photodiode, charge integration unit and a sample and hold stage. An automated switching between a low and a high sensitivity mode allows for a dynamic range of 17 bits. The integrated signals are read out, transferred to a printed circuit board (at a rate of 2463 Hz per pixel) and here converted into a digital data stream. The structured cadmium tungstate scintillator features lead stripes between pixels to reduce x-ray crosstalk and to shield the underlying in-pixel electronics. During assembling care was taken to ensure that the lead stripes of the scintillator entirely cover the pixel electronics underneath. Several prototype modules have been assembled and their performance concerning linearity, noise, crosstalk, and temperature dependence has been evaluated.
Digital indirect-detection x-ray imagers with microlens focusing: effects of Fresnel reflections from the microlens layer
We have been investigating whether a microlens layer placed between the phosphor and the photodetector can improve indirect detection x-ray imagers. Using a simulation study, we analyzed the light collection properties of the proposed imager taking into account Fresnel reflection and transmission properties of the lenses and the screen. A digital x-ray imager combining an 82-μm-thick Gd2O2S:Tb phosphor screen, a fused silica microlens layer, and a 127-μm pixel pitch photodetector (optical fill factor of 57%) were modeled. The light collection for the prototypes varied from 53% to 69% for lens thicknesses ranging from 10 to 50 μm. The full-width half-maximum (FWHM) of the light spread function ranged from 177-192 μm. 4-8% of the light was reflected back into the phosphor screen when correctly taking into account Fresnel reflections for these prototype imagers. In comparison, 56% of the light was collected and the FWHM of the light spread function was 174 μm for a conventional imager with the screen in direct contact with the photodetector. We observed that the light collection was overestimated by 6-9% but the spread functions were basically unaffected when the Fresnel assumption was not utilized in the simulations. This study shows that a properly designed microlens layer can more than offset Fresnel losses, thereby producing an improved digital x-ray imager.
Study of the detective quantum efficiency for the kinestatic charge detector as a megavoltage imaging device
Megavoltage x-ray imaging suffers from relatively poor contrast and spatial resolution compared to diagnostic kilovoltage x-ray imaging due to the dominant Compton scattering in the former. Recently available amorphous silicon/selenium based flat-panel imagers overcome many of the limitations of poor contrast and spatial resolution that affect conventional video based electronic portal imaging devices (EPIDs). An alternative technology is presented here: kinestatic charge detection (KCD). The KCD uses a slot photon beam, high-pressure gas (xenon, 100 atm) and a multi-ion rectangular chamber in scanning mode. An electric field is used to regulate the cation drift velocity. By matching the scanning speed with that of the cation drift, the cations remain static in the object frame of reference, allowing temporal integration of the signal. KCD imaging is characterized by reduced scatter and a high signal-to-noise ratio. Measurements and Monte Carlo simulations of modulation transfer function (MTF), noise power spectrum (NPS) and the detective quantum efficiency (DQE) of a prototype small field of view KCD detector (384 channels, 0.5 mm spacing) were carried out. Measurements yield DQE[0]=0.19 and DQE[0.5cy/mm]=0.01. KCD imaging is compared to film and commercial EPID systems using phantoms, with the KCD requiring an extremely low dose (0.1 cGy) per image. A proposed cylindrical chamber design with a higher ion-collection depth is expected to further improve image quality (DQE[0]>0.25).
Standardization of NPS measurement: interim report of AAPM TG16
Andrew D. A. Maidment, Michael Albert, Phillip C. Bunch, et al.
This article reviews the state of the Noise Power Standard being drafted by Task Group No. 16 for the American Association of Physicists in Medicine. The Standard is intended to represent a consensus on acceptable practices in the measurement and reporting of noise power spectra for digital radiographic imaging devices based on single projections and to contain informative sections which will be of use to those not completely familiar with the measurement and interpretation of noise power spectra. Several of the issues considered by the committee are reviewed, including issues of conditioning and windowing data, issues specific to several modalities, and various methods of data presentation. A note on the historical background of noise power measurements and a brief discussion of possible avenues for future research is included.
Breast Imaging III
icon_mobile_dropdown
Phase contrast digital mammography using molybdenum x-ray: clinical implications in detectability improvement
We have applied phase imaging on digital mammography to investigate adequate contrast of printed images for digital phase contrast mammography using a practical molybdenum X-ray tube. Phase contrast mammography procedures were performed with defined air gap (e.g., 0.6 m) configuration using customized mammography equipment and a computed radiography (CR) system. Magnified (x2) phase contrast images acquired with 0.0875mm per pixel were mapped onto the laser imager resolution at 0.04375mm per pixel for printing life-size object on wet processing silver halide recording film. For contact mammography of screen-film system, we used MinR2000 system as a baseline method. ACR 156 phantom printed images with contrasts of 2.8, 3.7, 4.9, 5.7 and 6.7 were evaluated by five radiologists. The ACR scores for the life-size image based on the 2 times magnified phase contrast image acquired by the computed radiography were higher than the scores of MinR2000 image, when the contrast of printed images for both methods was 3.7. The ACR scores were lower in the low contrast images (i.e., 2.8) than its higher contrast counterparts (i.e., >= 3.7) for all techniques used. The detectability improvement should be due to higher spatial resolution and lower noise in the phase contrast images.
New design of a structured CsI(Tl) screen for digital mammography
Vivek V. Nagarkar, Sameer V. Tipnis, Valeriy B. Gaysinskiy, et al.
Columnar CsI(Tl) screens are now routinely used for digital x-ray imaging in a wide variety of applications such as mammography, dental radiography, and non-destructive testing. While commercially available CsI(Tl) screens exhibit excellent properties, it is possible to significantly improve their performance. Here, we report on a new design of a columnar CsI(Tl) screen. Specifically, columnar CsI(Tl) screens were subjected to mechanical pixelation for minimizing the long range spread of scintillation light within the film, thus enhancing spatial and contrast resolution, and increasing the detective quantum efficiency (DQE(f)) of the digital imaging detector. To date we have fabricated up to 200 μm thick pixelated CsI(Tl) screens for mammography, and characterized their performance using a CCD camera. This paper presents a comparison of the new pixelated CsI(Tl) screens, conventional columnar CsI(Tl) screens, and Gd2O2S(Tb) screens. The data show that pixelated screens substantially improve the DQE(f) of the digital imaging system.
Measurements on a full-field digital mammography system with a photon counting crystalline silicon detector
Mats Lundqvist, Mats Danielsson, Bjoern Cederstroem, et al.
Sectra Microdose is the first single photon counting mammography detector. An edge-on crystalline silicon detector is connected to application specific integrated circuits that individually process each photon. The detector is scanned across the breast and the rejection of scattered radiation exceeds 97% without the use of a Bucky. Processing of each x-rays individually enables an optimization of the information transfer from the x-rays to the image in a way previously not possible. Combined with an almost absence of noise from scattered radiation and from electronics we foresee a possibility to reduce the radiation dose and/or increase the image quality. We will discuss fundamental features of the new direct photon counting technique in terms of dose efficiency and present preliminary measurements for a prototype on physical parameters such as Noise Power Spectra (NPS), MTF and DQE.
Performance of advanced a-Si/CsI-based flat-panel x-ray detectors for mammography
Douglas Albagli, Heather Hudspeth, George E. Possin, et al.
The GE Senographe 2000D, the first full field digital mammography system based on amorphous Silicon (a-Si) flat panel arrays and a Cesium-Iodide (CsI) scintillator, has been in clinical use for several years. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate and quantify improvements in the detective quantum efficiency (DQE) for both typical screening and ultra-low exposure levels for this technology platform. A new figure of merit, the electronic noise factor, is introduced to explicitly quantify the influence of the electronic noise, conversion factor, modulation transfer function (MTF), and pixel pitch towards the reduction of DQE at low exposure levels. Methods to improve the DQE through an optimization of both the flat panel design and the scintillator deposition process are discussed. The results show a substantial improvement in the DQE(f) at all frequencies and demonstrate the potential for DQE(0) to exceed 80%. The combination of high DQE at ultra low exposures and the inherent fast read-out capability makes this technology platform ideal for both current clinical procedures and advanced applications that may use multiple projections (tomosynthesis) or contrast media to enhance digital mammography.
Image quality of direct conversion detectors for mammography and radiography: a theoretical comparison
Direct conversion detectors have the potential to provide very high resolution and high detective quantum efficiency (DQE). Selection of a material that is appropriate for the task is dictated by the material properties. A linear cascaded systems analysis of DQE is used to predict the performance of several detector materials such as amorphous Se, CdZnTe, and PbI2. A model is used to predict the spatial frequency-dependent DQE(f) for each material. This model includes: (1) x-ray absorption, (2) K fluorescence, (3) conversion gain, and (4) incomplete charge collection. A depth-dependent approach is used to account for gain variations and charge transport characteristics that change throughout the detector. In the model a parallel cascade, and non-elementary stages are used to model the effect of K-fluorescence reabsorption followed by incomplete charge collection. The DQE(f) is determined across an x-ray energy range of 10 to 100 keV for each material under typical bias conditions ranging from 0.1 V/μm to 10 V/μm. K-fluorescence escape and reabsorption blurring can cause marked reductions in the DQE(f). It is further reduced by incomplete charge collection which can theoretically decrease the DQE(f) by as much as 50% in extreme situations. This model will help determine key factors that will influence material selection for direct conversion x-ray systems.
Optimizing beam quality for x-ray computed mammotomography
The purpose of this study was to determine the optimum beam quality in terms of kVp and filtration for a tungsten-target x-ray source for a newly developed cone beam computed mammotomography application. The optimized beam is expected to yield enhanced image quality along with a low dose, equal to or less than that of dual view x-ray mammography. X-ray spectra were computer generated for a range of tube potentials, filter materials, and filter and breast thicknesses. The uncompressed breast was modeled from 8, 12, and 16 cm thick tissue, and breast lesions were modeled as a 0.5 cm thick striated muscle mass and a 0.02 cm thick microcalcification. The detector was modeled as a digital flat-panel detector with a 0.06 cm thick CsI x-ray absorption layer. Figures of merit computed included the ratio of the mean beam energy post-breast to pre-breast as an index of beam hardening, ratio of lesion contrasts with and without filtering, and SNR/exposure. Tube potentials between 50 and 70 kVp provided continuous spectra that, when filtered with Z-filters between 56 and 62 yielded quasi-monochromatic x-ray spectra with optimal SNR/exposure and contrast while providing minimum beam hardening. Figures of merit improve with increasing filter thickness, but diminishing returns are seen beyond the 500th value attenuation layer. While uncompressed breast thickness affected absolute values of the measurement criteria, they had little effect on beam hardening and contrast ratio and did not alter the optimal operating range. Filter thickness near the 500th value layer is expected to be well within the operating range for an intended commercial x-ray tube, indicating that these highly attenuating filters can provide superior performance for mammotomography.
Poster Session
icon_mobile_dropdown
Quantitative proton radiography of an animal patient
Uwe Schneider, Matthias Dellert, Eros Pedroni, et al.
Images (with a spatial resolution of 1 mm x 1mm) were produced both, with range and range dilution information of the protons passing through a dog. The radiographies were taken prior to a proton radiotherapy treatment of a nasal tumor, while the dog patient was under anesthetics. The first image was created by calculating the mean range of the protons detected in each pixel. This image was compared to calculations of the treatment planning system based on a CT-scan of the dog. Errors in the calculated range could be detected. The second image was produced by calculating the width of the range spectrum in each pixel. This value is a measure of the dilution of the range due to tissue inhomogeneities. The dilution image can be used to indicate critical situations during proton therapy, to determine the safety margin around the tumor volume, or to optimise treatment. In a preliminary analysis of the radiography data we found range uncertainty and range dilution effects in the order of up to 10 mm.
Local convolution-deconvolution for resolution restoration and recovery in PET: a feasibility study
Sharok Kimiaei, Refaat Al-Mazrou, Omer Demirkaya
Positron Emission Tomography (PET) is one of the most popular methods for accurate localization and quantification of in vivo concentration of radioactivity. However, in most circular PET scanners, the inherent detector geometry results in a distance dependent and variant point spread function (PSF) in the image plane. Off-centered point sources are imaged with impaired spatial resolution in the radial direction resultng in elliptically shaped points. While some attempts have been made to correct for this unwanted image deterioration through incorporation of the variant detector blurring in the iterative reconstruction procedures, in most cases this effect has been disregarded and the images are uncorrected. In this paper we present and evaluate, by means of computer simulation, a novel approach for correction of the distance dependent and spatially variant point spread function in a two-step procedure. The projections are first homogenized through a non-linear convolution schema prior to reconstruction. In the second step, in order to compensate for the convolution performed in the first step, the spatially shift invariant images thus obtained are deconvolved using a conventional deconvolution method. The preliminary results show that the homogenization can completely remove the shift variant non-isotropic blurring in the image plane. Resolution of the images deconvolved with Lucy-Richardson deconvolution method was improved from 9 mm to 3 mm with maintained shift-invariance.
Space-dependent effects of motion on the standard deviation of fMRI signals: a simulation study
Remco Renken, Lucian Muresan, Hendrikus Duifhuis, et al.
In fMRI, any fluctuation of signal intensity, not recognized as a result of a specific task, is treated as noise. One source for “noise” is subject motion. Normally, motion effects are reduced by applying realignment. We investigate how apt a realignment procedure is in removing motion-related effects by comparing the distribution of the normalized standard deviation of each voxel, NSD (=standard deviation/mean), before and after realignment. We use data acquired from a simulation program developed previously. This program covers the effects of spin history, slice profiles, and motion in (f)MRI. We simulated inter-volume motion perpendicular to the slices of a digital, artificial head phantom, with and without spin history. In all cases, fluctuations in signal intensity were reduced after standard realignment. This effect was strongest when no spin history was present. Hence, spin history has a marked effect on the “noise.” The spatial distribution of NSD showed similarities to the structures of the brain. This indicates that (residual) motion effects were largest at the transitions between tissues. Possibly, the spatial distribution of NSD can provide a (independent) tool to investigate brain structure. Furthermore, the method presented can be used to qualitatively compare different “noise” reduction steps in fMRI data analysis.
Magnetic resonance current density image reconstruction in the spatial frequency domain
Soo Yeol Lee, Sang Chul Lee, Suk Hoon Oh, et al.
The purpose of this study is to improve noise immunity of electrical current density image reconstruction in magnetic resonance current density imaging (MRCDI) and magnetic resonance electrical impedance tomography (MREIT). In the MRCDI and MREIT techniques, electrical current densities have been calculated by taking curls to the extra magnetic fields generated by externally applied electrical currents. The extra magnetic fields are calculated from the phase information in magnetic resonance images. Both the phase calculations and curl operations are very sensitive to the noise. Since the curl operation in the space domain appears as a high pass filter in the spatial frequency domain and the current density images have very little high frequency components, we can adopt various kinds of spatial filtering techniques during the curl operation to improve the signal-to-noise ratio of the current density images. We have compared current density estimation results between the proposed and conventional methods for several kinds of current distribution patterns. For the current distributions with little high spatial frequency components, the proposed current density reconstruction method has been found to be superior to the conventional method.
Dynamic susceptometry technique for brain mapping
Soo Yeol Lee, Jong Soo Yang, Sang Chul Lee, et al.
We have analyzed magnetic field perturbations caused by local magnetic susceptibility changes at a brain when the brain is immersed in the main magnetic field of an MRI system. When a local region of brain tissue is activated, the effective magnetic susceptibility of the region changes due to the blood volume and blood oxygenation level changes at the activated region. This local susceptibility change will, then, perturb the main magnetic field of the MRI system. After estimating the effective magnetic susceptibility change at an activated region, we have analyzed the perturbation field through theoretical and numerical calculations. We have found that the magnetic field perturbation due to the local susceptibility change is as big as can be measured by SQUID devices. We expect that the perturbation field can be used for brain function studies in conjunction with fMRI.
Numerical evaluation of heating in the human head due to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
Uyen Nguyen, Steve Brown, Isaac Chang, et al.
In this paper we present a numerical model for evaluating tissue heating during magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Our method, which included a detailed anatomical model of a human head, calculated both the electromagnetic power deposition and the associated temperature elevations during a MRI head examination. Numerical studies were conducted using a realistic birdcage coil excited at frequencies ranging from 63 MHz to 500 MHz. The model was validated both experimentally and analytically. The experimental validation was performed at the MR test facility located at the FDA's Center for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH).
Distributed image reconstruction for an in-vivo mouse imaging system
Sang Chul Lee, Jae Yong Han, In Kon Chun, et al.
Mice have been widely used in various areas of biomedical research such as drug development and genetic engineering. To investigate drug effect or treatment efficacy in the mouse studies, in-vivo mouse imaging modalities have been recently developed. Among various kinds of imaging modalities, micro-CT is expected to be useful in many biological applications since it provides 3-dimensional high-resolution tomographic images. In this study, we have developed a high-resolution micro-CT system using a microfocus x-ray source and a flat panel detector. The flat panel detector contains a CsI scintillator plate, a 2-dimensional photodiode array, and a 12-bit ADC. The photodiode array consists of 2400 x 2400 pixels of 50μm size. In order to improve computing speed in the micro-CT, we have also developed a distributed parallel processing system using multiple computers. The computation-intensive cone-beam reconstruction process has been divided into multiple tasks in a way that each CPU takes care of similar amount of computations. We have linked four desktop computers with dual AMD Athlon processors by Ethernet and optimized the task allocations among them. The developed parallel processing system has shown to have about eight times faster reconstruction speed. It is expected that the distributed image reconstruction technique can be a low cost solution for the in-vivo mouse imaging system.
Two methods for modeling the propagation of terahertz radiation in a layered structure
Gillian Claire Walker, Elizabeth Berry, Stephen W. Smye, et al.
Terahertz (THz) radiation is being studied as an investigative tool for skin conditions. Two approaches for describing the propagation of THz radiation through skin are presented and verified using a layered water-based phantom. The skin was assumed to comprise a series of layers of tissue with differing, frequency dependent, properties; the major interaction was assumed to be between THz radiation and water. Based on these assumptions a thin film matrix model and a Monte Carlo model were developed to simulate this situation. In order to test these models, a simple three layer in-vitro phantom was used. This consisted of two 2 mm layers of TPX, encasing a 180 micrometer layer of a water/propanol-1 mixture. Spectroscopic measurements were made in a pulsed THz system for cells with thirteen different water/propanol-1 concentrations. Comparisons between the results from both models and experimental spectra show good correlation, in each case the model was able to simulate the overall trend of the spectra and more detailed features. This suggests that the models may be adapted to investigate THz irradiation of skin. Modeling modifications would include using layer dimensions that were comparable to the constituent layers of skin and using additional layers to describe the organ more thoroughly.
Physical characteristics of a clinical prototype for full-field digital mammography with an a-Se flat-panel detector
Barbara Lazzari, Giacomo Belli, Cesare Gori, et al.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate physical characteristics of a clinical prototype for full-field digital mammography (FFDM) with an amorphous selenium (a-Se) flat-panel detector (FPD) and to compare these results with the currently available systems for FFDM. The effective FPD area consists of 2816 x 2016 pixel matrix having a pixel pitch of 85μm. This yields to theoretical maximum spatial frequency of ~5.9lp/mm. The basic performance of Instrumentarium clinical prototype direct mammography system has been assessed on the basis of measured response curve, the modulation transfer function (MTF), the noise power spectrum (NPS), the noise equivalent quanta (NEQ) and the detective quantum efficiency (DQE) in the clinical setting. The system shows a linear response curve over a dynamic range from 0.4 mR to 57 mR. The presampling MTF was found to be approximately 0.91, 0.72 and 0.50 at 2, 4 and 5.9 (Nyquist frequency) lp/mm. The NEQ is linearly related to the exposure starting from about 8 mR above which value the system can be considered noise quantum limited. The DQE, evaluated in clinical conditions (28kVp Mo-Mo spectrum hardened by 4cm of PMMA) is at close to zero spatial frequency approximately 69% at 46.4 mR and 61% at 8.3 mR. Below 8 mR the DQE(0) falls to 54.4%, 46% and 32.5% at 5.2, 3.0 and 1.4 mR respectively due to structured and electronic noise. The results of quantitative analysis demonstrate a high MTF as we expected due to direct conversion technology and a high DQE over the exposure range from 8 mR to 50 mR. The NEQ shows that the system can be considered noise quantum limited above 8 mR suggesting the exposure level that should be set in the clinical practice to ensure an adequate image quality.
Theoretical LOR model incorporating spatial uncertainty in continuous detector PET
Steven Staelens, Yves D'Asseler, Michel Koole, et al.
In this paper, we will describe a theoretical model of the spatial uncertainty for a line of response, due to the imperfect localization of events on the detector heads of the Positron Emission Tomography (PET) camera. We assume a Gaussian distribution of the position of interaction on a detector head, centered at the measured position. The probability that an event originates from a certain point in the FOV is calculated by integrating all the possible LORs through this point, weighted with the Gaussian probability of detection at the LORs end points. We have calculated these probabilities both for perpendicular and oblique coincidences. For the oblique coincidence case it was necessary to incorporate the effect of the crystal thickness in the calculations. We found that the probability function can not be analytically expressed in a closed form, and it was thus calculated by means of numerical integration. A Gaussian was fitted to the probability profiles for a given distance to the detectors. From these fits, we can conclude that the profiles can be accurately approximated by a Gaussian, both for perpendicular as for oblique coincidences. The FWHM reaches a maximum at the detector heads, and decreases towards the center of the FOV, as was expected.
Image quality of flat-panel cone beam CT
We present results on 3D image quality in terms of spatial resolution (MTF) and low contrast detectability, obtained on a flat dynamic X-ray detector (FD) based cone-beam CT (CB-CT) setup. Experiments have been performed on a high precision bench-top system with rotating object table, fixed X-ray tube and 176 x 176 mm2 active detector area (Trixell Pixium 4800). Several objects, including CT performance-, MTF- and pelvis phantoms, have been scanned under various conditions, including a high dose setup in order to explore the 3D performance limits. Under these optimal conditions, the system is capable of resolving less than 1% (~10 HU) contrast in a water background. Within a pelvis phantom, even inserts of muscle and fat equivalent are clearly distinguishable. This also holds for fast acquisitions of up to 40 fps. Focusing on the spatial resolution, we obtain an almost isotropic three-dimensional resolution of up to 30 lp/cm at 10% modulation.
Volumetric restoration of tuned-aperture computed tomography
Paul F. Hemler, Timothy M. Persons, Robert J. Plemmons
Analytic determination of the 3D PSF of a tomosynthetic image volume allows us to solve the ill-posed inverse problem of recovering an image volume from a nonspecific orientation of projection views. To restore these inherently blurred images from tuned-aperture reconstructed volumes, we consider three approaches; direct inversion via 3D Wiener filter restoration, regularized iterative 3D conjugate gradient least squares, and regularized nonlinear iterative 3D modified residual norm steepest descent with nonnegativity constraints. From these tests we infer that all three methods produce adequate restorations, while the nonlinear, nonnegatively constrained iterative algorithm appears to produce especially good restorations for this problem in an efficient and stable way.
Monte Carlo study of x-ray cross talk in a variable resolution x-ray detector
Roman Melnyk, Frank A. DiBianca
A variable resolution x-ray (VRX) detector provides a great increase in the spatial resolution of a CT scanner. An important factor that limits the spatial resolution of the detector is x-ray cross-talk. A theoretical study of the x-ray cross-talk is presented in this paper. In the study, two types of the x-ray cross-talk were considered: inter-cell and inter-arm cross-talk. Both types of the x-ray cross-talk were simulated, using the Monte Carlo method, as functions of the detector field of view (FOV). The simulation was repeated for lead and tungsten separators between detector cells. The inter-cell x-ray cross-talk was maximum at the 34-36 cm FOV, but it was low at small and the maximum FOVs. The inter-arm x-ray cross-talk was high at small and medium FOVs, but it was greatly reduced when variable width collimators were placed on the front surfaces of the detector. The inter-cell, but not inter-arm, x-ray cross-talk was lower for tungsten than for lead separators. From the results, x-ray cross-talk in a VRX detector can be minimized by imaging all objects between 24 cm and 40 cm in diameter with the 40 cm FOV, using tungsten separators, and placing variable width collimators in front of the detector.
Basic performance evaluation of the first model of a four-dimensional CT scanner
Shinichiro Mori, Masahiro Endo, Takanori Tsunoo, et al.
We have developed a prototype of 4-dimensional (4D) CT-scanner that employs continuous rotation of cone-beam. Because a cone-beam scan along a circle orbit did not collect a complete set of data to make rigid reconstruction of volume (3D image), it might bring disadvantages or artifacts. To examine effects of the cone-beam data collection on image quality, we have evaluated basic performances of the prototype and compared them to those of a state-of-the-art multi-detector (MD) CT-scanner. As the results image characteristics such as noise, uniformity, high contrast and low contrast detectability of 4D CT were independent of z-coordinate, and comparable to those of MD CT. The transverse spatial resolution of 4D CT was independent of z-coordinate, and showed slightly better performance than that of MD CT, while the longitudinal spatial resolution of 4D CT was the same as the transverse one, and much better than that of MD CT in the present scan conditions. Isotropic resolving power of 0.5mm was achieved for 4D CT. A Feldkamp artifact was observed in distortion measurement though its clinical meaning has not been clarified. Exposure dose measured with CT dose index (CTDI) for 4D CT was comparable to that for MD CT. As a whole our first model of 4D CT-scanner was successful to take a volume data of 10cm long along longitudinal direction in a single rotation scan with comparable image quality and exposure dose to the state-of-the-art MD CT-scanner.
Flat-panel detector-based cone beam volume CT breast imaging: detector evaluation
Yong Yu, David L. Conover, Ruola Ning
Preliminary evaluation of large-area flat panel detectors (FPDs) indicates that FPDs have some potential advantages over film-screen and CCD-based imagers: compactness, high resolution, high frame rate, large dynamic range, small image lag (<1%), and excellent linearity (~1%). A real time large-area flat panel detector (FPD) Varian PaxScan 2520 was evaluated for cone-beam volume breast imaging (CBVCTBI) in terms of dynamic range, linearity, image lag, and spatial as well as low contrast resolution. In addition, specially made breast phantoms were imaged with our prototyped CBVCTBI system to provide real outcomes to evaluate the detector under full imaging system conditions including the x-ray source, gantry geometry, x-ray technique selection, data acquisition system and reconstruction algorithms. We have concentrated on the low kVp range (30 to 80 kVp) in the context of the breast-imaging task. For ~288 images/scan the exposure required was ~2.5mR/projection. This is equivalent to that of a conventional mammography screening exam. The results indicate that the FPD-based CBVCTBI system can achieve sufficient high- and low-contrast resolution for diagnostic CBVCT breast imaging with a clinically acceptable exposure level. The advantages of the new FPD make it a promising candidate for CBVCTBI.
Point spread function deconvolution in 3D micro-CT angiography for multiscale vascular tree separation
Suzanne T. Witt, Christian H. Riedel M.D., Mario Goessl M.D., et al.
Micro-CT angiography of small laboratory mammal organs visualizes vascular branches on a large range of scales, ranging from root-level branches (~ 1 mm) to endarteriolar vessels (10-40 μm). Multiscale vascular tree segmentation is facilitated by the ability to set a single grayscale threshold value for vessels of all generation levels. Due to the non-ideal modulation transfer function (MTF) of the imaging system, object contrast varies significantly with scale, and the definition of a grayscale threshold for vessel segmentation becomes a problem. We found that performing a point spread function (PSF) deconvolution on the micro-CT projection images significantly reduces the thresholding problem in terms of restoring the smallest vessels' grayscale and delineation. The increased noise from performing a PSF deconvolution will not have a significant effect on the overall signal-to-noise ratio of the images. The PSF deconvolution was successful only when it accommodated the spatial variation of the PSF.
Accurate perspective projection calculation using a pixel-pyramid model for iterative cone beam reconstruction
The calculation of perspective projection is the essential part in either cone-beam projection or realistic volume rendering. In this paper, we propose a pixel-pyramid model to accurately calculate pixel values in flat-panel-based cone-beam reconstruction. This model faithfully portrays the divergent beam projection on a grilled planar detector. It consists of a pyramidal base (detector pixel facet) and an apex (X-ray source). Through spatial clipping by a flat-panel detector (FPD), a cone is tailored into a pyramid with the base at the FPD, called FPD pyramid, which is then spatially decomposed into pyramidal elements (PYREL). During cone-beam projection, a PYREL intersects the 3D object and produces a frustum, wherein the voxels are accumulated to produce a pixel value. In backprojection, the pixel value is imparted to the same contributive voxels. A voxel’s weight (contribution to a PYREL) is determined by spatial overlapping, which is a piecewise linear function. Through iterative algorithm, accurate cone beam reconstruction is achieved. Since the pyrel model portrays the perspective projection geometry and the voxel weight in a more natural fashion, it can be used for accurate calculation of perspective projection, especially in dealing with severe incomplete data. Simulations and comparisons are provided.
Simulation of scatter in cone beam CT: effects on projection image quality
Alexandr Malusek, Michael P. Sandborg, Gudrun Alm Carlsson
Cone-beam computed tomography (CT) projections were calculated by the Monte Carlo method for two cylindrical water phantoms of different sizes and for an antropomorphic voxel phantom with and without the presence of an anti-scatter grid. The scatter-to-primary ratio (SPR) was evaluated for each projection and the dependence of the amount of scattered radiation on the phantom size, cone beam size, photon energy, and antiscatter grid was investigated. It was found that the amount of scattered radiation is a slowly varying function of position in the image plane whose values, depending on configuration parameters, may cover a range of several magnitudes. The SPR reflects changes in the amount of primary photons and may reach values around 5 for large phantoms, wide beams and 120 kV spectrum or even higher values for low energy photons.
Effects of collimation and reconstruction algorithm on noise using low-dose lung cancer screening CT techniques
The effects of collimation and reconstruction algorithm on image noise in CT were investigated using several low dose techniques typical of lung cancer screening protocols. Tube current settings were 10mA, 20mA, 50mA, and 100 mA, all at 120kVp and 0.8 sec rotation time. A homogeneous water phantom was scanned with various mA setting, collimation, and reconstruction algorithm combinations. Noise was measured under each condition and radiation doses for each tube current used were extrapolated from CTDIw values measured at each collimation. Noise values for each mA, collimation, and algorithm combination were compared as a function of radiation dose (CTDIw) and were also compared with the noise and radiation dose values of currently employed lung cancer screening techniques (e.g. 120 kVp, 50 mA, .8 sec, 2.5 mm collimation, bone reconstruction algorithm). The data shows that thinner slices (those < 2.5 mm) at the same mA setting and reconstruction algorithm yield higher noise values and higher radiation dose values than current techniques, as high as nearly 3 times the original CTDIw. In lung cancer screening imaging with CT, moving to thinner slices presents some difficult tradeoffs between dose and noise. Reconstruction algorithm can be used to reduce image noise, but at a price of reduced in-plane spatial resolution, offsetting some of the benefit of using thinner slices to detect smaller lesions.
Adaptive noise reduction toward low-dose computed tomography
An efficient noise treatment scheme has been developed to achieve low-dose CT diagnosis based on currently available CT hardware and image reconstruction technologies. The scheme proposed includes two main parts: filtering in sinogram domain and smoothing in image domain. The acquired projection sinograms were first treated by our previously proposed Karhunen-Loeve (K-L) domain penalized weighted least-square (PWLS) filtering, which fully utilizes the prior statistical noise property and three-dimensional (3D) spatial information for an accurate restoration of the low-dose projections. To treat the streak artifacts due to photon starvation, we also incorporated an adaptive filtering into our PWLS framework, which selectively smoothes those channels contributing most to the streak artifacts. After the sinogram filtering, the image was reconstructed by the conventional filtered backprojection (FBP) method. The image is assumed as piecewise regions each has a unique texture. Therefore, an edge-preserving smoothing (EPS) with locally-adaptive parameters to the noise variation was applied for further noise reduction in image domain. Experimental phantom projections acquired by a GE spiral computed tomography (CT) scanner under 10 mAs tube current were used to evaluate the proposed smoothing scheme. The reconstructed imaged demonstrated that the smoothing scheme with appropriate control parameters provides a significant improvement on noise suppression without sacrificing the spatial resolution.
Design and construction of a flat-panel-based cone beam volume computed tomography (FPD-CBVCT) imaging system through the adaptation of a commercially available CT system: work in progress
David L. Conover, Ruola Ning, Rongfeng Yu, et al.
The purpose of this presentation is to show how a commercially available spiral CT can be modified for use as the electro-mechanical scanner hardware for a prototype flat panel detector-based cone beam volume computed tomography (FPD-CBVCT) imaging system. FPD-CBVCT has the benefits of isotropic high resolution, low contrast sensitivity and 3D visualization. In contrast to spiral CT, which acquires a series of narrow slices, FPD-CBVCT acquires a full volume of data (limited by the cone angle and the FPD active area) in one <= 360° scan. Our goal is to use a GE HighSpeed Advantage (HSA) CT system as the basis for an FPD-CBVCT imaging prototype for performing phantom, animal and patient imaging studies. Specific electromechanical and radiographic subsystems to be controlled include: gantry rotation and tilt, patient table positioning, rotor control, mA control, the high frequency generator (kVp, exposure time, repetition rate) and image data acquisition. Also, a 2D full field FPD needs to replace the 1D detector, as well as the existing slit collimator needs to be retrofitted to a full field collimator to allow x-ray exposure over the entire active area of the FPD. In addition, x-ray projection data acquisition needs to be performed at >=30 fps. Power and communication signals to control modules on the rotating part of the gantry will be through integrated slip rings on the gantry. Through the synchronized control of the pulsed x-ray exposures, data acquisition, gantry rotation and tilt, as well as the position and translation speed of the patient table, the system will be able to achieve spiral cone beam and circle-plus-arc cone beam image acquisition protocols. Performance will be evaluated with optical encoders, standard dosimetry equipment and phantom studies.
Compact high-speed computed radiography (CR) system using a linear CCD with a large-area photodiode (PD) and dual transfer lines
Satoshi Arakawa, Hiroaki Yasuda, Takao Kuwabara, et al.
We performed an image quality simulation for the line scan system, which realizes a compact and high-speed Computed Radiography (CR) system. The line scan system uses a line light source and a linear CCD sensor. In this system, the emitted light must be efficiently focused onto the CCD sensor to detect the emitted light as much as possible. To realize the effective light detection, we analyzed the spread of the light in the photostimulable phosphor layer. We also estimated the image quality based on X-ray absorption, the amount of emitted light, light collecting efficiency and electric noise. It clarified the image quality is affected strongly by such factors as the spread of the PSL, the size of photo diodes of the CCD sensor and electric noise.
Electronic readout of a-Si EPIDs for optimum signal-to-noise ratio
Farhad A. Ghelmansarai, Satrajit Misra, Jean Pouliot
Three acquisition schemes for a-Si flat panels are described for radiation therapy imaging. The goal of all three acquisition modes is to acquire images with the highest achievable SNR (signal to noise ratio). The acquisition modes are Single mode for low dose acquisition (used for patient positioning), external continuous mode used for patient treatment (verification), and Cone Beam mode for mega-voltage computed tomography (MVCT). During single mode acquisition, a few frames are readout prior to the start of irradiation. During this cycle, the accumulated dark current and residual data are cleared. During the radiation delivery no readout occurs, and the signal is integrated over the entire exposure period. After the irradiation readout occurs. The advantages of this readout scheme are to reduce the effects of readout noise and eliminate the linear accelerator (linac) pulsing effects on the final image. There is no readout during the exposure; therefore, no beam pulsing artifacts occur. Since the signal is integrated during the exposure time and the readout is performed after the exposure, this improves the SNR compared to acquiring a few frames during the radiation and averaging these frames to create the final image. The single mode acquisition is used clinically routinely and allows the acquisition of clinical images with a small amount of exposure (<=2 MU). During external trigger continuous mode, the linear accelerator pulsing artifacts are removed by synchronizing the frame readout with linear accelerator pulses. The pulsing artifacts reduce the signal to noise ratio. This degradation is in the range of 70% for a single frame acquisition with 6MV, 300MU/min X-ray beam. Frame averaging reduces the degradation. The Cone beam acquisition mode is used to perform volume MVCT in the cone beam geometry to visualize 3D (three dimensional) anatomy during patient positioning. In this mode the image acquisition is synchronized with the linear accelerator, which enables the imager to remove linear accelerator pulsing artifacts from the image and also provides the charge integration during low dose imaging. This synchronization improves the SNR.
Development and evaluation of a selenium-based flat-panel digital x-ray detector system based on quality factor
Nowadays, large area, flat panel solid state detectors are being investigated for digital radiography. In this paper, development and evaluation of a selenium-based flat-panel digital x-ray detector are described. The prototype detector has a pixel pitch of 139μm and a total active imaging area of 7"× 8.5", giving a total of 1.9 million pixel. This detector include a x-ray imaging layer of amorphous selenium as a photoconductor which is evaporated in vacuum state on a TFT flat panel, to make signals in proportion to incident x-ray. The film thickness was about 500μm. To evaluate the imaging performance of the digital radiography (DR) system developed in our group, sensitivity, linearity of the response of exposure, the modulation transfer function (MTF) and detective quantum efficiency (DQE) of detector was measured. The measured sensitivity was 4.16 x 106 ehp/pixel•mR at the bias field of 10 V/μm: The beam condition was 41.9 KeV. Measured MTF at 2.5 lp/mm was 52%, and the DQE at 1.5 lp/mm was 75%. And the excellent linearity was showed where the coefficient of determination (r2) is 0.9693.
Imaging with high dynamic using an ionization chamber
Ralf-Hendrik Menk, Francesco Voltolina
In this work a combination of an ionization chamber with one-dimensional spatial resolution and a MicroCAT structure will be presented. The combination between gas gain operations and integrating front-end electronics yields a dynamic range as high as eight to nine orders of magnitude. Therefore this device is well suitable for medical imaging or applications such as small angle x-ray scattering, where the requirements on the dynamic of the detector are exceptional high. Basically the described detector is an ionization chamber adapted to fan beam geometry with an active area of 192 mm and a pitch of the anode strips of 150 micrometer. In the vertical direction beams as high as 10 mm can be accepted. Every read-out strip is connected to an analogue integrating electronics channel realized in a custom made VLSI chip. A MicroCAT structure utilized as a shielding grid enables frame rates as high as 10kHz. The high dynamic range observed stems from the fact that the MicroCAT enables active electron amplification in the gas. Thus a single photon resolution can be obtained for low photon fluxes even with the integrating electronics. The specialty of this device is that for each photon flux the gas amplification can be adjusted in such a fashion that the maximum DQE value is achieved.
Energy-dependent quantum detective efficiency (QDE) measurements of a photon-counting CdTe detector array used for the scanning-beam digital x-ray (SBDX) system
Koji Iwata, Josh M. Star-Lack, Edward G. Solomon, et al.
The Scanning-Beam Digital X-ray (SBDX) system utilizes a scanning x-ray pencil beam and a small-area detector array for low-dose cardiac angiography with tomographic imaging capabilities. For the system to provide adequate signal-to-noise ratios, the multi-element detector must be highly efficient and capable of high photon count rates. Cadmium telluride (CdTe) is well suited to these purposes. The CdTe SBDX detector is a direct-conversion photon-counting device consisting of 2304 elements. The efficiency of the detector is a function of several factors including the incident photon energy, the fluorescence properties of CdTe, and the discriminator threshold that determines whether sufficient energy was deposited in an element to register a count. For maximum efficiency, the discriminator threshold must be set low enough to detect CdTe k-fluorescence photons (23-31 keV), but not so low as to register false counts from electronic noise. The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the energy-dependent quantum detective efficiency (QDE) of a new lower-noise SBDX detector design and to determine whether adequately low thresholds can be achieved. Experiments were performed using metal fluorescer foils to generate quasi-monochromatic x-ray beams with energies of 17.5, 25.3, and 46.0 keV. The resulting spectral purities were high, although fluence rates were low. The measured QDE values at 17.5, 25.3, and 46.0 keV were 60%, 76%, and 86% repsectively.
Contrast-to-noise and exposure measurements of an aSi:H/Csl(Tl) flat-panel based digital radiography system using a QC chest phantom
Xinming Liu, Chris C. Shaw, Peter Balter, et al.
The amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) flat panel imaging systems have recently become commercially available and gained acceptance as promising candidates for implementing digital radiography. In this work, SNRs, CNRs and figure-of-merit, defined as CNR2/SEEs, were measured for a commercial a-Si:H/CsI(Tl) flat-panel digital chest radiography system as a function of the kVp for three different regions in the images of a chest phantom: lung, heart and subphrenic. Using these measurements, issues of image quality and optimal selection of the kVp are discussed.
Photon-counting energy-sensitive micropattern gas detector for digital radiography
Mustafa C. Altunbas, Eugene Franklin Barasch, Daniel R. Bednarek, et al.
A photon counting energy sensitive micro-pattern gaseous detector is being developed for projection radiography. Two cascaded gas electron multipliers (GEMs) are used as gain stages following a drift region that acts as an absorption volume. Active area of the detector is 7cm x 7cm and the signal is read out by 0.2 mm pitch strips. An aluminum pressure vessel was designed as an integral part of the detector, which operates at pressures up to 10 atm. Voltage-gain curves were obtained for Ar and Kr mixtures. Energy resolution for a 5.9 keV Fe-55 was determined to be 20% FWHM. Energy spectra for a conventional x-ray generator operating at various voltages were also obtained. Detector MTF and DQE were calculated using linear systems analysis. The effect of primary electron range, a dominant factor in determining spatial resolution, and the effect of fluorescent photon reabsorption were studied. Operation of the detector for imaging at higher pressures with Kr and Xe mixtures is in progress.
Basic evaluation of physical characteristics and clinical study of new digital subtraction angiography system with a large-area flat-panel detector
Kenji Okusako, Masachika Shogaki, Katsuhisa Tanaka, et al.
Authors could have a clinical experience to use an angiographic system incorporating FPD. This system possesses both FPD and I.I.-CCD detectors and is capable of conducting imaging in the same geometry for both detectors. We made measurement of basic physical characteristics of this system and visual evaluation using arteriographies of lower limbs processed by IVDSA, and confirmed that FPD is an excellent detector in angiographic examination. In the foreseeable future, angiographic system will be replaced by FPD system.
X-ray detection properties of polycrystalline Cd1-xZnxTe detectors for digital radiography
Sang Sik Kang, Ji Koon Park, Dong Gil Lee, et al.
There has been considerable recent progress in II-IV semiconductor materials and in methods for improving performance of the associated digital x-ray detectors. Cd1-xZnxTe is known as promising medical x-ray detector material. The CdTe and Cd1-xZnxTe (x=0.15,0.25,0.3) detectors were fabricated by vacuum thermal evaporator for the large area deposition. First, the stoichimetric ratio and the x-ray diffraction of the deposited (Cd,Zn)Te films were analyzed by EPMA and XRD. Secondly, leakage current, x-ray sensitivity, SNR, and linearity were measured to analyze the x-ray detection effect of Zn in (Cd,Zn)Te film. Experimental results showed that the increase of Zn concentration rates in Cd1-xZnxTe detectors reduced the leakage current and improved the x-ray detection performance.
Improvement of the temporal response and output uniformity of polycrystalline CdZnTe films for high-sensitivity x-ray imaging
Satoshi Tokuda, Hiroyoki Kishihara, Susumu Adachi, et al.
X-ray detectors that we developed utilizing polycrystalline CdZnTe films exhibited superior sensitivity, but inadequate temporal response and output uniformity for medical imaging purposes. In order to improve those deficiencies, we tested new procedures for deposition and post-deposition chemical-heat treatment of polycrystalline CdZnTe films, in addition to investigating new device structures. We doped the polycrystalline CdZnTe films with Cl in a new manner so as to achieve effective grain boundary passivation. Polycrystalline CdZnTe films that were Cl-doped by our new procedure were found to have a finer and more uniform grain structure. We fabricated and evaluated devices with a replaced barrier layer against charge injection under negative bias. All these measures helped reduce the temporal lag of a 300 μm thick polycrystalline CdZnTe film exposed to X-ray irradiation. Moreover, utilizing this film in a detector reduced the detector's output uniformity. We have succeeded in improving the X-ray temporal response and output uniformity of a 300 μm thick CdZnTe film. This study will also discuss countermeasures against a number of problems that were encountered, including MTF degradation and short range image lag.
Differences between mono- and poly-energetic spectra in modeling DQE(f)
Most theoretical calculations of DQE are done assuming a mono-energetic beam, whereas, clinically, the systems are used with poly-energetic spectra. Using a cascaded stochastic model of a mammographic imaging system, we compared results using mono-energetic beams to mammographic poly-energetic beams. The effects of the depth of x-ray interaction in the phosphor were explicitly included in the model. We calculated DQE, MTF and NPS as a function of spatial frequency and also calculated the Swank noise factor (AS) and quantum detection efficiency (AQ). For mono-energetic beams between 15 and 40 keV, the AS changed from 0.80 to 0.84, and the AQ decreased from 0.90 to 0.16. For the spatial-frequency dependent measures, at 10 cycles/mm, the MTF increased from 0.09 to 0.16, the ratio of MTF squared to the relative NPS increased from 0.13 to 0.29, and DQE decreased from 0.19 to 0.06. These values were compared to poly-energetic x-ray calculations assuming molybdenum and tungsten anodes in the range of 24 to 40 kVp. Good agreement to within 5% in DQE at all spatial frequencies was found. However, at high kVp, the mono-energetic approximation overestimated the AS and underestimated the AQ by as much as 10%.
Simple method for modulation transfer function determination of digital imaging detectors from edge images
Egbert Buhr, Susanne Guenther-Kohfahl, Ulrich Neitzel
A simple variant of the edge method to determine the presampled modulation transfer function (MTF) of digital imaging detectors has been developed that produces sufficiently accurate MTF values for frequencies up to the Nyquist frequency limit of the detector with only a small amount of effort for alignment and computing. An oversampled edge spread function (ESF) is generated from the image of a slanted edge by rearranging the pixel data of N consecutive lines that correspond to a lateral shift of the edge of one pixel. The original data are used for the computational analysis without further data preprocessing. Since the number of lines leading to an edge shift of one pixel is generally a fractional number rather than an integer, a systematic error may be introduced in the MTF obtained. Simulations and theoretical investigations show that for all frequencies up to the Nyquist limit the relative error ΔMTF/MTF is below 1/(2N) and can thus be kept below a given threshold by a suitable choice of N. The method is especially useful for applications where the MTF is needed for frequencies up to the Nyquist frequency limit, like the determination of the detective quantum efficiency (DQE).
Novel method for automated determination of the cancellation parameter in dual-energy imaging: evaluation using anthropomorphic phantom images
Dual-energy imaging shows increased conspicuity and specificity of lung nodule detection through the removal of undesired contrast resulting from overlying bone structures. We have developed an algorithm that automatically determines the optimal cancellation parameters for a log-subtraction technique for a pair of high- and low-energy images. The core algorithm involves shrinking the data, extracting bone features, extracting salient edge from these bone features, calculating a tissue-cancellation map, computing the maximum-likelihood bone contrast cancellation parameter, and finally, calculating the soft-tissue cancellation parameter using an empirical relationship. We verified the performance of the algorithm using observer studies, in which the value of the tissue-cancellation parameter calculated by the algorithm was compared to the value manually selected by nineteen trained observers. A number of dual-energy images were acquired with a modified GE Revolution XQ/i, flat-panel-detector chest imaging system, using an anthropomorphic phantom. The effects of variables such as patient size, kVp, mAs, lung texture, patient motion, and the presence of foreign objects in field-of-view on algorithmic performance were evaluated. We found that the algorithm-selected parameter values had less variability than those selected by the observers. Furthermore, the algorithm-selected parameter was within the limits of the variability of the observers for all cases.
Use of MTF calculation in global and local resolution assessment in digital mammography
The purpose of this study is to propose a test procedure for global and local resolution assessment in digital mammography to detect sharpness problems. The MTF calculation was based on the presampled edge method. In a first phase, we compared the effect of geometry and exposure conditions on the MTF. Results were: (1) the MTF was reproducible; (2) MTF data can be corrected for edge angle; (3) scatter conditions have significant influence; (4) edge position in the detector plane has negligible influence; (5) the required edge length for our algorithm is longer than the critical length to get rid of noise effects; (6) exposure conditions have no major influence except at very low dose levels. We propose to approximate clinical working conditions for the global MTF-check, with an edge-object embedded in 45mm PMMA and clinical exposures. Localized MTF calculations with this phantom and software can be automated for QA by the medical physicist. For sharpness analysis all over the detector, we designed a test-object with oblique, parallel bars and automatic software tools are being developed. By means of software simulations, local variations in the sharpness could be detected. Validation in practice and further automation of the software tools is ongoing.
General approach to optimizing digital mammography with respect to radiation risk
Kent M. Ogden, Walter Huda, Ernest M. Scalzetti
We investigated how current biological uncertainties relating to the radiation risks for breast cancer impact on the optimization of x-ray tube potential (kV) in digital mammography. Digital images were taken of an accreditation phantom using voltages between 24 and 34 kV, and output between 5 and 500 mAs. The average glandular dose (D) at each x-ray tube voltage was determined at each technique setting. Image contrast of a 4 mm thick acrylic disk and the corresponding noise were used to determine the lesion contrast to noise ratio (CNR), which was taken as a relative measure of image quality when the selected x-ray technique factors (i.e., kV/mAs) are varied. The optimal kV for the detection of this simulated mass lesion was determined by maximizing a figure of merit (FOM), the ratio of CNR2/D. The kV that maximized the traditional FOM occurred at 27.3 kVp. The implication for optimization strategies was also analyzed for a radiation risk that is proportional to Dn; a value of n = 0 would correspond to no additional radiation risk, and n = 2 would correspond to a quadratic dose response curve. The x-ray voltage that yielded the highest generalized FOM value was 34 kV for n < 0.25, and 24 kV for n > 1.5. These results show that uncertainties in the form of the dose response curve for radiation induced breast cancer markedly influence the FOM parameter used for optimizing digital radiography imaging systems such as mammography.
Semiempirical adjustments to bremsstrahlung model for x-ray production from CT tubes
Flávio Augusto Penna Soares, Danilo de Paiva Almeida
In this study, we carried out an analytical description for the x-ray bremsstrahlung spectrum generated by a Toshiba CT Scanner installed in a Public Hospital in São José, Brazil. The goal is to obtain simple empirical equations that predict the photon yield in good agreement with measured results. The new points developed by this study are: (a) the use of recommended and more accurate databases of stopping power for electrons by thick materials; (b) a new normalization procedure is proposed to impose the energy conservation between total photon emitting and total electron bremsstrahlung energy loss; (c) a new approach to radiation self-attenuation. A complete database of stopping power for electrons by thick materials is available from National Institute of Standards and Technology Physics Reference Data. These data have an uncertainty of 5% in medical x-ray energy levels. These points are improved with respect to previous models, which use many complex empirical equations to predict electron and self-attenuation behaviors. The electron energy as a function of the depth penetrated into the thick target is described through the experimental electronic energy loss. The penetration function has been found to be similar to the Thomson-Whiddington equation but with different exponential dependence.
Laser-based intense hard x-ray source for mammography
Liming M. Chen, Patrick Forget, R. Toth, et al.
Characteristic Kα emissions from Mo, Ag and La targets irradiated by 60 fs, 600 mJ, 10 Hz Ti: Sapphire laser pulse at 1017 W/cm2 - 1019 W/cm2 can be potentially used in x-ray mammography. We have investigated x-ray spectra created by this novel x-ray source in this context. All the obtained spectra exhibited a dominating narrow emission lines with only a small portion of x-ray emission in Bremsstrahlung. Such spectra might be very usful in mammography and might improve contrast and dose utilizaion, as compared to a conventional mammographic x-ray tube. The effective focal spot size was of the order of 50 μm, i.e. significantly smaller than in conventional mammography. In contradiction to conventional mammography the effective x-ray focal spot size and the effective dose remained constant across the field of view. Kα conversion efficiency, from laser light to x-rays, was optimized and values as high as 2 x 10-5 have been obtained.
Theoretical and empirical characterization of the physical characteristics of a clinical digital mammography system
The physical performance characteristics of a clinical full-field digital mammography (FFDM) system were analyzed for different target/filter conditions using theoretical modeling and experimental measurements. The signal and noise propagation through the various stages of the FFDM system was simulated as a cascaded process and used to compute the frequency dependent detective quantum efficiency (DQE) of the system. The presampling modulation transfer function (MTF) of the system and the noise power spectra (NPS) of the system were measured under the different spectral conditions as used in the theoretical model at an exposure close to 10-mR from which corresponding DQEs were computed. The experimental zero frequency DQE after filtering the x-ray beam through 45-mm acrylic was estimated at 0.51, 0.48, and 0.46 for Mo/Mo, Mo/Rh, and Rh/Rh respectively. A good agreement between the theoretical and experimental results was observed. The clinical digital mammography system appears to exhibit favorable physical characteristics and similar models could be used to design and optimize other imaging systems.
3D visualization of pathological forms from MRI data obtained with simultaneous water and fat signal suppression
Yuri A. Pirogov, Nikolai V. Anisimov, Leonid V. Gubski
For enhancement of visualization and 3D image reconstruction of intracranial pathological forms, it is suggested to use MR images obtained with simultaneous water and fat signal suppression. In this case one can more distinctly reveal pathological forms which are hidden ordinarily under powerful signals of fat tissue (orbits and hypodermic fat) and free water (brain ventricles). To realize simultaneous suppression of strong water and fat signals, we use modified sequence "inversion-recovery" supplemented by second inversion pulse. The signal/noise ratio degrades insignificantly in comparison with common "inversion-recovery" technique. Yet due to suppression of intensive background signals the dynamic range of the receiver extends and its responsiveness to weak signals improves. Herewith the graphical data processing and construction of 3D images are significantly simplified as tissue contrast picture is maximally refined. The method is illustrated by 3D images in the cases of subdural haematomas and intracranial tumors. Drawing of 3D images for pathological forms was carried out by the standard software of MR scanner TOMIKON S50 (Bruker) which was used in MRI investigations.
Improving 3D image quality of x-ray C-arm imaging systems by using properly designed pose determination systems for calibrating the projection geometry
Norbert K. Strobel, Benno Heigl, Thomas M. Brunner, et al.
C-arm volume reconstruction has become increasingly popular over the last years. These imaging systems generate 3D data sets for various interventional procedures such as endovascular treatment of aneurysms or orthopedic applications. Due to their open design and mechanical instability, C-arm imaging systems acquire projections along non-ideal scan trajectories. Volume reconstruction from filtered 2D X-ray projections requires a very precise knowledge of the imaging geometry. We show that the 3D image quality of C-arm cone beam imaging devices can be improved by proper design of the calibration phantom.
Detective quantum efficiency of the LODOX system
The Detective Quantum Efficiency (DQE) of a digital x-ray imaging system describes how much of the signal to noise ratio of the incident radiation is sustained in the resultant digital image. This measure of dose efficiency is suitable for the comparison of detectors produced by different manufacturers. The International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) stipulates standard methods and conditions for the measurement of the DQE for single exposure imaging systems such as flat panel detectors. This paper shows how the calculation is adapted for DQE measurements of scanning systems. In this paper it is described how to measure the presampled Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) using an edge test method and how to extract the horizontal and vertical components of the Noise Power Spectrum (NPS) in a way that is insensitive to structured noise patterns often found in scanned images. The calculation of the total number of incident photons from the radiation dose measurement is explained and results are provided for the Lodox low dose full body digital x-ray scanning system which is developed in South Africa.
Gibbs ringing artifact and spatial correlation in MRI
Gibbs ringing artifact is a type of image distortion which manifests itself as spurious ringing around sharp edges. It is an inevitable result of truncating the Fourier Series due to missing of high-frequency data or finite sampling. Most studies on Gibbs ringing artifact focus on its effect on image resolution. Our study will show its link to spatial correlation in the image. Based on the theory of signal processing and statistical communication, three types of MR signals and two types of k-space samples are studied. k-space samples in MRI data acquisition are shown to be independent Gaussians. Based on Fourier Transform (FT) and Filtered Backprojection (PR) image reconstruction algorithms and using Linear system theory, pixel intensities in the reconstructed MR image are shown to be asymptotically independent. The quantitative measures of this local dependence are derived. Our study reveals that finite k-space sampling introduces pixel-to-pixel correlation in the reconstructed MR image. This kind of data acquisition protocol and FT/PR reconstruction turn independent k-space samples into correlated image pixels. This finding and the derived formulae provide a basis for further development in MRI statistical study and stochastic model-based MR image analysis strategies.
X-ray tube in parallel magnetic fields
Our hybrid x-ray/MR system (a fixed-anode x-ray fluoroscopic system in an interventional MR system) provides the high spatial and temporal resolution of x-ray fluoroscopy with the soft-tissue contrast, 3D visualization and physiological information of MRI. X-rays are produced in an x-ray tube by bombarding a target with high-energy electrons, ionized from the cathode, then accelerated by the electric field between the cathode and anode. In the hybrid system, the x-ray tube is placed in a high magnetic field, aligned to be parallel to the cathode-anode axis of the tube. A finite-element program was used to simulate the electron trajectories in a geometry similar to our fixed anode tube. External magnetic fields parallel to the cathode-anode axis, ranging from 0 to 0.5T, were simulated. Experimentally, focal spot images were acquired using a 30μm pinhole at a magnification of 8.9 in magnetic fields ranging from 0 to 0.5T. No lateral deflection of the focal spot was observed in either the simulation or the experiment, if the magnetic field and the cathode-anode axis were aligned, regardless of the field strength. However, the field strength affected the size and the current density distribution of the focal spot. We conclude that fixed anode x-ray tubes can be used in a magnetic field although its desired electron optics must be fairly “straight” and the cathode-anode axis must be well aligned with the field. Further issues arising from the focal spot size change, such as overheating of the target, and to a lesser extent the system spatial resolution, should be carefully considered.
Grangeat-type half-scan algorithm for cone beam CT
Currently, various cone-beam CT scanners are under rapid development for major biomedical applications. Half-scan cone-beam image reconstruction algorithms are desirable, which assume only part of a scanning turn, and are advantageous in terms of temporal resolution. While the existing half-scan cone-beam algorithms are in the Feldkamp framework, we formulate a half-scan algorithm in the Grangeat framework for circular and helical trajectories. First, we modify the Grangeat formula in the circular half-scan case. With analytically defined boundaries, the Radon space is partitioned into shadow zone, singly and doubly sampled regions, respectively. A smooth weighting scheme is designed to compensate for data redundancy and inconsistency. The sampled regions are linearly interpolated into the shadow zone for a complete data set. Then, these concepts and formulas are extended to the helical half-scan case. Extensive numerical simulation studies are performed to verify the correctness and demonstrate the performance. Our Grangeat-type half-scan algorithms allow minimization of redundant data and optimization of temporal resolution, and outperform Feldkamp-type reconstruction in terms of image artifacts. These algorithms seem promising for quantitative and dynamic biomedical applications of cone-beam tomography.
Evaluation of reconstruction accuracy of cone beam volume CT breast imaging for different scanning orbits
Ruola Ning, Xianghua Lu, Biao Chen, et al.
Conventional screen film mammography is the most effective tool for the early detection of breast cancer currently available. However, conventional mammography has relatively low sensitivity for detecting small breast cancers (under several millimeters). Specificity and the positive predictive value of mammography remain limited owing to an overlap in the appearance of benign and malignant lesions, and surrounding structure. We propose to address the limitations accompanying conventional mammography by incorporating a cone beam volume CT (CBVCT) reconstruction technique with a recently developed flat panel detector. In this study, we present the results obtained from a computer simulation study and a breast-imaging phantom experimental study to find out the reconstruction accuracy of different cone beam volume scanning orbits for CBVCTBI, and to determine if different partial scan protocols (less than 360°) are appropriate for breast cancer detection. Three types of CBVCTBI scanning orbits were simulated using an uncompressed breast phantom. The reconstruction accuracy was evaluated as a function of different scanning orbits assuming reconstruction with 360° was the gold standard. The results indicate that with 180° plus cone angle orbit, the reconstruction error is below 4% that is in the acceptable range. In addition, a preliminary phantom study using both 360° and 180° plus cone angle orbits, was conducted on the current flat panel detector-based CBVCT prototype scanner. The companion CBVCT reconstruction images of an uncompressed breast-image phantom are presented.
Imaging performance of a clinical selenium flat-panel detector for advanced applications in full-field digital mammography
Vincent Loustauneau, Michel Bissonnette, Sebastien Cadieux, et al.
The advent of digital detectors will enable several advanced imaging applications to be used in the fight against breast cancer. For example, dynamic imaging applications such as tomosynthesis, contrast enhanced and dual energy mammography have demonstrated promising results. In this paper, we will assess the suitability of this detector for these advanced applications. MTF and DQE measurements were performed on a selenium FFDM detector to assess image quality. Ghosting properties of a digital detector are also an important factor, since it can strongly degrade image quality. In this paper, we will also report on the ghosting characteristics of the selenium detector, using typical exposures envisioned to be used in tomosynthesis exams. The physical mechanisms that create ghost images will be discussed and will be quantified.
Detection and labeling ribs on expiration chest radiographs
Mira Park, Jesse S. Jin, Laurence S. Wilson
Typically, inspiration is preferred when xraying the lungs. The x-ray technologist will ask a patient to be still and to take a deep breath and to hold it. This not only reduces the possibility of a blurred image but also enhances the quality of the image since air-filled lungs are easier to see on x-ray film. However, inspiration causes low density in the inner part of lung field. That means that ribs in the inner part of lung field have lower density than the other parts nearer to the border of the lung field. That is why edge detection algorithms often fail to detect ribs. Therefore to make rib edges clear we try to produce an expiration lung field using a 'hemi-elliptical cavity.' Based on the expiration lung field, we extract the rib edges using canny edge detector and a new connectivity method, called '4 way with 10-neighbors connectivity' to detect clavicle and rib edge candidates. Once the edge candidates are formed, our system selects the best candidates using knowledge-based constraints such as a gradient, length and location. The edges can be paired and labeled as superior rib edge and inferior rib edge. Then the system uses the clavicle, which is obtained in a same method for the rib edge detection, as a landmark to label all detected ribs.
New K-edge-balanced contrast phantom for image quality assurance in projection radiography
X-ray-absorber step-wedge phantoms serve in projection radiography to assess a detection system's overall exposure-related signal-to-noise ratio performance and contrast response. Data derived from a phantom image, created by exposing a step-wedge onto the image receptor, are compared with predefined acceptance criteria during periodic image quality assurance (QA). For contrast-related measurements, in particular, the x-ray tube potential requires accurate setting and low ripple, since small deviations from the specified kVp, causing energy spectrum changes, lead to significant image signal variation at high contrast ratios. A K-edge-balanced, rare-earth-metal contrast phantom can generate signals that are significantly more robust to the spectral variability and instability of exposure equipment in the field. The image signals from a hafnium wedge, for example, are up to eight times less sensitive to spectral fluctuations than those of today’s copper phantoms for a 200:1 signal ratio. At 120 kVp (RQA 9), the hafnium phantom still preserves 70% of the subject contrast present at 75 kVp (RQA 5). A copper wedge preserves only 7% of its contrast over the same spectral range. Spectral simulations and measurements on prototype systems, as well as potential uses of this new class of phantoms (e.g., QA, single-shot exposure response characterization) are described.
Two-dimensional optoacoustic tomography of large-scale phantoms
Alexander M. Reyman, Grigory P. Volkov, Ivan V. Yakovlev, et al.
The aim of present report is to demonstrate some new approaches in OA imaging. An optoacoustic (OA) method for non-invasive diagnostics allows to detect inhomogeneities (defects) differing from surrounding tissues with their optical absorption -- the only way to obtain information about optical properties of deep tissue layers. An experimental setup for 2D OA imaging includes pulsed light source (Nd:YAG laser), a set of acoustical receivers with amplifiers, computer-based system for data acquisition and scanning control and specialized software for image reconstruction. We used quasi-resonant ultrasonic receivers in 2-5 MHz frequency range with various directivities. Various methods of OA scanning: mechanical rotating transmission system, set of fixed low-directive receivers, transducer phased arrays and single-probe mechanical angle scanners -- have been studied and discussed. Artificial phantoms simulating biological tissues were used in the experiments as well as samples of real soft tissues. Experimentally obtained OA tomograms of phantoms containing optical inhomogeneities have acceptable contrast; measured geometrical dimensions correspond to real object parameters. The results of the performed investigation have been showed that angular scanning system is preferable for OA imaging of human organs because it provides one-side access to the body and is based on ultrasonic transducers widely used in ultrasonic imaging. This work was supported by Russian Foundation for Basic Research (Projects # 00-02-16600, 03-02-17042) and 6th competition-expertise of young scientists of Russian Academy of Sciences (Project #399).
High-resolution medical imaging system for 3D imaging of radioactive sources with 1-mm FWHM spatial resolution
This paper describes a modification of a new imaging system developed at Argonne National Laboratory that has the potential of achieving a spatial resolution of 1 mm FWHM. The imaging system uses a crystal diffraction lens to focus gamma rays from the radioactive source. The medical imaging application of this system would be to detect small amounts of radioactivity in the human body that would be associated with cancer. The best spatial resolution obtained with the present lens at the time of the presentation made at the Medical Imaging Symposium 2001, was 6.7 mm FWHM for a 1-mm-diameter source. Since then it has been possible to improve the spacial resolution of the lens system to 3 mm FWHM. Experiments with the original lens system have led to a new design for a lens system that could have a spacial resolution of 1 mm FWHM. This is accomplished by: one, reducing the radial dimension of the crystals, and two, by replacing the small individual crystals with bent strips of single-crystalline material. Experiments are under way to test this approach.
Use of a film scanner as a microdensitometer for optical transfer function and focal spot measurements
This work presents a computational model for practical application of the transfer function method for radiographic units evaluation, in order to reduce some experimental constraints involved to its determination. With the proposed algorithm, the complete Optical Transfer Function (Modulation Transfer Function and Phase Transfer Function) can be easily determined as well as the effective focal spot sizes at any field location without using a microdensitometer. All measurements are done from a digitized slit image obtained experimentally at the field center position. The effective focal spot sizes can be calculated by using the Line Spread Function Root Mean Square (RMS) value or by the Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) first minimum. Besides, considering the variation of the effective focal spot size given by the field characteristic equations, all these parameters can also be determined at any location on the radiation field. The computer scheme was used for evaluating slit images obtained from nine different x-ray equipments. Results confirmed the possibility of using the transfer function method for quality evaluation of any radiological system in a simple and automatic way. This computer scheme replaces some of the expensive and specific devices necessary to the experimental MTF evaluation by quite more accessible and low cost equipments.